By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - Mario 3DS and Zelda SS will flop

EDIT: This thread is more of a "I wish Mario 3DS and Zelda SS were flops, because I don't like the direction the series is going and I want them to return to the SMB and Z1 gameplay upon this failing."

--

http://www.gametrailers.com/video/gdc-11-zelda-skyward/711140

http://static.arstechnica.net/assets/2011/03/nintendo_gdc_intro-thumb-640xauto-19924.jpg

Disclaimers: Yes I am judging immediately from very limited screenshots/video, and flop means in financial expectations of Nintendo not that it won't sell a million.

Mario 3DS

Look at the screenshot. Particularly the left edge of the lower left image. It's the edge of a floating platform. Also the ? block. It's reusing art assets from Galaxy/Galaxy 2.

It's Super Mario Galaxy 3.

Due to this and being in the same position as Super Mario 64 DS (3D Mario near launch), I think it will sell less than either of SMG2 and SM64DS and be the weakest selling main Mario game ever. From what I can see it has nothing to attract new people to Mario if they didn't already like Galaxy; it doesn't look like a coherent Mushroom Kingdom and looks like a linear series of arbitrary platforming challenges (contrast Mario 64's large worlds to explore).

Zelda SS

The art style and music are surprisingly similar to Galaxy to me. It retains the Ocarina gameplay style (puzzles and enemies acting as puzzles) and the swordfighting didn't look very immersive on the trailer (as in 1:1). So it is an Ocarina sequel in a long line of Ocarina sequels that brings nothing new and nothing to attract casual players.

It doesn't retain Twilight Princess's advantage of being the only good launch game, so I would like to compare it to Majora's Mask. I think it will sell less than that lifetime (<3.36m per VGC).



Around the Network

Flop? No, even if they end up being the worst games ever made (yeah like that's gonna happen) they willl still not 'flop'

not meet expectations quality wise or sales wise? who knows, kinda early to tell imho



In-Kat-We-Trust Brigade!

"This world is Merciless, and it's also very beautiful"

For All News/Info related to the PlayStation Vita, Come and join us in the Official PSV Thread!

Doubtful, but everyone is intitled to their opinion. 



 

I can see why specially Zelda SS is at risk of low sales (low like only a few millions) but Mario 3DS will do fine even with all the lack of innovation (apparently, so far)



 

 

 

 

 

 I'm skeptical on Mario 3D. Very much feels like a Wii game on a handheld, which is something that doesn't typically do brilliant. I'd rather they just release it on the Wii tbh >_>.

 Zelda will do alright, but it's not going to set the world alight like Mario Kart or NSMB. It'll get a solid 5m or so.



Around the Network

Mario 3DS

NO WAY!!!

Zelda : SS

Maybe...



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

I think he's joking... and if he's not... even if Mario 3DS was terrible, it would still sell 10mil plus.



some one close this useless thread -_-



               

There's no way that's Super Mario Galaxy 3.

It might be Mario Galaxy 3DS, though. But it won't be "Super" (it seems like they keep that word for console Mario's) nor "3".