I'd like to know what your favourite games are, can you please list them. It'd be easier to take you seriously if you actually mentioned what you were comparing these games to, because nearly every fault you gave to each game, I could give to heaps other books, movies and other games. It's like you created this thread with the intention of ruffling a few feathers and hoping that people label you as the 'Outsider' gamer who loves games that either bombed, involves some sort of effeminate lead  or has a small cult following.

Only one Wii game.

Not that bad of a list at all.  :p

you might get him to rant about the wii now if i remembre :P

Do not believe him!!!! He is clearly under control by Seraphic_Sixaxis!!!

Now go back to love Uncharted 2.

I'm trying.

Good detective work iBlah. I am know back on the loving side.

I agree with most of your Points. Uncharted 2 is the most overrated game of all times for me. Uncharted2 has nothing speciall, the Shooterpart of Uncharted 2 ist boring, no variety every time comes the same opponent, and the  "Platforming" sections are really REALLY linear that you feel the game is playing itself for you. The story of Uncharted 2 is bullshit. Uncharted 2 was a big disappointment for me.  UC2 deserves not more then 80%.  

I think the entire FPS genre is wildly overrated

Funny. I agree on every game.

I agree with most of it, but I don't think Fallout and Red Dead should be on there. Definitely agree with Resistance and Uncharted, but where the hell is Halo?