Everything in this thread is a complete rip off of what Stickball did, but I think it's a good idea to do one of these for every system and handheld.  So, make your nominations for each category below.

Edit:  I've added the category "Platformer" so that MP3 and SMG can be put in more proper genres.  I have also add best party game and best sports game categories.  Please edit your responses to match this.  

Best Graphics:

Best Sound Effects:

Best Replay Value:

Best Music/Soundtrack:

Best Story:

Best Multiplayer:

Most Innovative Feature in a Game:

Most Innovative Game:

In specific catagories:

Best First/Third Person Shooter:

Best Racing Game:

Best RPG:

Best Action/Adventure Game:

Best Platformer:

Best Party Game:

Best Sports Game:

Best Virtual Console Game:

Game of the Year (all genres):

Turd/Letdown of the Year:

Best Graphics: Super mario galaxy

Best Sound Effects: Super mario galaxy

Best Replay Value: Super mario galaxy

Best Music/Soundtrack: Super mario galaxy

Best Story: Super mario galaxy

Best Multiplayer: Super mario strikers

Most Innovative Feature in a Game: gravity.. Super mario galaxy

Most Innovative Game: Super mario galaxy



In specific catagories:

Best First/Third Person Shooter:Metroid prime 3

Best Racing Game: Excite truck

Best RPG:

Best Action/Adventure Game:Super mario galaxy

Best XBLA Game: WHAT DA F??!?!





Game of the Year (all genres): Super mario galaxy

Turd/Letdown of the Year:Boogie

That's easily Geometry Wars, the only XBLA game to make it to the Wii so far. =P

Best Graphics: Super Mario Galaxy

Best Sound Effects: Resident Evil 4 Wii Edition

Best Replay Value: Resident Evil : Umbrella Chronicles

Best Music/Soundtrack: Super Mario Galaxy

Best Story: Metroid Prime 3 : Corruption

Best Multiplayer: Medal of Honor Heroes 2

Most Innovative Feature in a Game: (2D/3D change) Super Paper Mario

Most Innovative Game: Zack & Wiki : Quest for Barbaros' Treasure



In specific catagories:

Best First/Third Person Shooter: Metroid Prime 3 : Corruption

Best Racing Game: Excite Truck

Best RPG: Super Paper Mario (meh)

Best Action/Adventure Game: Zack & Wiki : Quest for Barbaros' Treasure

Best Virtual Console Game: The Legend of Zelda : Ocarina of Time



Game of the Year (all genres): Super Mario Galaxy

Turd/Letdown of the Year: Cruisin', Soul Calibur Legends

wii GOTY galaxy
will do the other categories shortly will try to think of them better

Best Graphics: Super Mario Galaxy

Best Sound Effects: Super Mario Galaxy

Best Replay Value: Super Mario Galaxy

Best Music/Soundtrack: Super Mario Galaxy

Best Story: Trauma Center: Second Opinion

Best Multiplayer: Wii Sports

Most Innovative Feature in a Game: Use Of Wiimote in Wii Sports

Most Innovative Game: Wii Sports



In specific catagories:

Best First/Third Person Shooter: Metroid Prime 3: Corruption

Best Racing Game: Excite Truck

Best RPG: Super Paper Mario

Best Action/Adventure Game: Super Mario Galaxy

Best XBLA Game: BWAAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!



Game of the Year (all genres): Super Mario Galaxy

Turd/Letdown of the Year: Boogie

Best Graphics: Melty Molten

Best Sound Effects: Gusty Garden

Best Replay Value: Sweet Sweet Galaxy

Best Music/Soundtrack: Gusty Garden

Best Story: The Library

Best Multiplayer: Bouldergeist

Most Innovative Feature in a Game: Star-bit gathering

Most Innovative Game: Monkey-ball Green Challenge

Turd/Letdown of the Year: Naznatips putting an XBLA category in the Wii edition

Best Graphics:SMG

Best Sound Effects: SMG

Best Replay Value: MOH:H2

Best Music/Soundtrack: SMG

Best Story: MP3

Best Multiplayer:MOH:H2

Most Innovative Feature in a Game:2D/3D SPM

Most Innovative Game: zack and wiki

In specific catagories:

Best First/Third Person Shooter:MP3

Best Racing Game:need for speed

Best RPG:SPM

Best Action/Adventure Game:RE4

Best Platformer:SMG

Best Party Game:Wii play

Best Sports Game: Madden 08

Best Virtual Console Game:SMB3

Game of the Year (all genres):SMG

Turd/Letdown of the Year:Dewys adventure

I didn't vote in some. I don't hate any Wii game that I play. and for multi-player, there are ties and so I didn't vote in that.

Oh, and this is my 1,000TH POST! ^_^