I am only voting for games I have played or in the least seen in the flesh.
Best Graphics: SMG - Seen Not played
Best Sound Effects:Tigger Woods Golf
Best Replay Value:RRR
Best Music/Soundtrack:Thrillville: Off the Rails
Best Story:Zelda TP
Best Multiplayer:RRR
Most Innovative Feature in a Game:Thrillville
Most Innovative Game:Wii Sports
In specific catagories:
Best First/Third Person Shooter: NA
Best Racing Game: NA
Best RPG: NA
Best Action/Adventure Game:Zelda TP
Best Platformer:
Best Party Game: RRR
Best Sports Game: Tiger Woods
Best Virtual Console Game: Toe Jam & Earl 2
Game of the Year (all genres):
Letdown of the Year: