Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 19 - Game Thread

@noname

When you asked me what I thought about a lynch, I didn't answer there and then because I stumbled upon an idea. Sorry it took me so long to respond but my answer is yes. I'm for a day one lynch.

Here's what was crossing my mind when I roleclaimed.

Kratos as a serial killer would be more beneficial to the mafia because he would randomly kill people (i.e town or mafia). If I treat him, he would strictly pursue mafia. Me mentioning that he will have the doctors protection most likely didn't sit well with mafia, so it's only natural that they would try to find a way to debunk my story. 

What I'm saying is. Anyone who came up with a highly thought hypothetical situation to try to put a hole in my roleclaim, is probably mafia.

based on what i said and what you guys think. what say you that we put my theory to test and lynch someone who fits that description?

Btw

FoS Khuutra and Silver-Tiger



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

Around the Network
hatmoza said:

@noname

When you asked me what I thought about a lynch, I didn't answer there and then because I stumbled upon an idea. Sorry it took me so long to respond but my answer is yes. I'm for a day one lynch.

Here's what was crossing my mind when I roleclaimed.

Kratos as a serial killer would be more beneficial to the mafia because he would randomly kill people (i.e town or mafia). If I treat him, he would strictly pursue mafia. Me mentioning that he will have the doctors protection most likely didn't sit well with mafia, so it's only natural that they would try to find a way to debunk my story. 

What I'm saying is. Anyone who came up with a highly thought hypothetical situation to try to put a hole in my roleclaim, is probably mafia.

based on what i said and what you guys think. what say you that we put my theory to test and lynch someone who fits that description?

Btw

FoS Khuutra and Silver-Tiger

Well even though I am normally heavily against a first day lynch.  Your idea has piqued my interest ever so slightly.  What you say does make sense,  so I would support this idea. 



hatmoza said:

@noname

When you asked me what I thought about a lynch, I didn't answer there and then because I stumbled upon an idea. Sorry it took me so long to respond but my answer is yes. I'm for a day one lynch.

Here's what was crossing my mind when I roleclaimed.

Kratos as a serial killer would be more beneficial to the mafia because he would randomly kill people (i.e town or mafia). If I treat him, he would strictly pursue mafia. Me mentioning that he will have the doctors protection most likely didn't sit well with mafia, so it's only natural that they would try to find a way to debunk my story. 

What I'm saying is. Anyone who came up with a highly thought hypothetical situation to try to put a hole in my roleclaim, is probably mafia.

based on what i said and what you guys think. what say you that we put my theory to test and lynch someone who fits that description?

Btw

FoS Khuutra and Silver-Tiger

I'm one of the guys who dismissed the notion that you were Mafia because it would be suicidal.



Lovely first day going on. Nice to see that it's not the no-lynch and wait tradition.

Silver-tiger is certainly being suspicious trying to stop hatmoza with highly convoluted theories.

Seriously, hatmoza's role claim seems pretty genuine and I don't see a reason to poke at it.

FoS: Silver-tiger



Kimi wa ne tashika ni ano toki watashi no soba ni ita

Itsudatte itsudatte itsudatte

Sugu yoko de waratteita

Nakushitemo torimodosu kimi wo

I will never leave you

TruckOSaurus said:
TruckOSaurus said:
Kantor said:
TruckOSaurus said:

OMG! You're right! Bad Khuutra bad!

Kantor I want answers! Why did you feel you needed to change your statement?

I realised we hadn't started yet, and didn't want to start discussing the game.

FoS TruckOSaurus for prosecuting me so relentlessly.

I wasn't prosecuting you, I was merely asking for information. Changing the wording of a sentence like you did has to have a good reason, something that  motivates the action. I thought you could be a baddie thinking he said too much or someone with an important role who didn't want to attract attention but I checked out the times of your post and edit and it fits with what you just said so I'm content for now.

Yes I'm quoting myself...

I wanted to ask a follow up question to Kantor. What was it that made you think the game wasn't started yet? GodofWar's post listing people who didn't post or Khuutra telling me to back off until the day starts?

GoW3Ever. I'm pretty sure Khuutra told you that after I'd edited



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

gamrReview - Arthur Kabrick | My All-Time Top 50 | 2013 Metascores

                                        

Around the Network
Silver-Tiger said:
Nikells said:
Silver-Tiger said:

At this point it would damn stupid for the SK to come out. We have no proof that hatmoza really is telling the truth, maybe he is lying about his role and just wants the SK to come forward so he is an easy lynch target. Of course that would be good for the town, but honestly I don't think the SK would risk a lynch so early in the game.

If Hatmoza was lying how would he know the serial killer was Kratos though?

We don't know if Hatmoza is genuine or not: but the SK does.

That is true. On the other hand, who else could be the Serial Killer other than Kratos? I mean, I've never played any God of War game (don't worry, I plan to get the trilogy soon, shame on me for getting it so late, though) but I do know that he pretty mich kills every god, right? So it would be only natural that he is the SK. Call me paranoid, but I just don't trust hatmoza so easily.

Ares could be the serial killer. He destroys a whole bunch of cities.

Now, I'm finding it a little hard to keep up with this. Is Patapon Kratos, or is Hatmoza?



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

gamrReview - Arthur Kabrick | My All-Time Top 50 | 2013 Metascores

                                        

Kantor said:
Silver-Tiger said:

That is true. On the other hand, who else could be the Serial Killer other than Kratos? I mean, I've never played any God of War game (don't worry, I plan to get the trilogy soon, shame on me for getting it so late, though) but I do know that he pretty mich kills every god, right? So it would be only natural that he is the SK. Call me paranoid, but I just don't trust hatmoza so easily.

Ares could be the serial killer. He destroys a whole bunch of cities.

Now, I'm finding it a little hard to keep up with this. Is Patapon Kratos, or is Hatmoza?

Neither (that we know of).

Patapon claimed to be Kratos but later took it back.

Hatmoza is pretty much confirmed to be Athena, who is looking for Kratos. Kratos is also pretty much confirmed to be the serial killer.

I find your lack of attention disturbing



Are there any lurkers who haven't posted yet? I'd imagine they'd be Kratos.



Kimi wa ne tashika ni ano toki watashi no soba ni ita

Itsudatte itsudatte itsudatte

Sugu yoko de waratteita

Nakushitemo torimodosu kimi wo

I will never leave you

I think everyone has posted at least once now, if only once, lol, so its kinda hard to say who is or isnt lurking.

I guess an idea is to see who the people who posted least are?



Kantor said:
TruckOSaurus said:

Yes I'm quoting myself...

I wanted to ask a follow up question to Kantor. What was it that made you think the game wasn't started yet? GodofWar's post listing people who didn't post or Khuutra telling me to back off until the day starts?

GoW3Ever. I'm pretty sure Khuutra told you that after I'd edited


Mmm yeah that makes sense but what I don't get is that your post was made AFTER GodofWar posted his list so you should have been under the impression the game wasn't started from to moment you first posted which would mean the edit was done for another reason...



Signature goes here!