The latest gametrailers bonus round has a couple of reactions from E3, and GOTY choices thus far!
Shane satterfield, editor and chief of gametrailers, believes compared to KILLZONE 3, HALO REACH is very well behind and not just visually, but he believes it is far too arcady, in fact he considers it one of his biggest dissapointments at E3, this was in response to what one guy said about HALO REACH being the big jump from halo 2 to 360 that he had been waiting for.
Speaking of dissapoinments the entire Bonus round interviewers believes EPIC MICKEY was another one of the biggest dissapointments, saying that not only are the visuals very sub par(when watching it in person) but the camera needs a lot of work, as does the gameplay.
They also were given choices to pick between GOTY candidates, Geoff said GOD OF WAR III due to how epic the game felt, Shane says SUPER MARIO GALAXY 2 due to variety, the other two say RED DEAD and SMG2.
more here