the characters could look a bit more detailed, but the rest is fantastic.

It's not bashing if it's the truth. 360 fans dont need to hide on this site.

Unfortunately I think that you are wrong selnor. Did you saw the Halo Reach vidoc in HD? Halo Reach will feel like a sandbox game with exploration, 100 enemies at once with impressive graphics. Yes, Alan Wake really looks incredible and the light effects are unreal, I am really impressed with some parts in the new trailer but Halo Reach will be huge!

I think we will see a good fight between Halo Reach and Alan Wake but Alan Wake will have the second place for console graphics king in my opinion.

But both games are impressive, it will be a hard decision.

I agree in a different way. Alan Wake looks better from a technial screens point of view. But Reach looks to have the best engine this generation has seen. The visuals together with the draw distances with 100+ enemies is gonna look amazing. Gamespot has already said Reach is amazing in motion. It's the only game which aklso has more than 30 different AI scripts running at one time. It's the pinnacle of engines this gen.

Go checkout the latest posts on the GOW3 trailer, one trailer and its proclaimed the greatest graphics ever, a generation apart, blah, blah ,blah.  Don't even try to pretend the 360 userbase is anywhere close to the PS3 userbase for living in cloud cuckoo land when it comes to hyping graphics.  Lets not even get started on Lair, Haze, Infamous, etc, etc.  It wouldn't matter if he posted in a more civil and mild mannered tone, the PS3 trolls of which there is a hugne number that far exceed every other console would be all over the thread bashing it.

What's your point? They are keeping the comments in a news post or official thread. Not making new threads calling out 360 fans or purposely trying to wind people up.

Do you have threads regarding the graphics of Lair, Haze and inFamous... Claiming they were the best graphics ever?

The "PS3 trolls" who come into the threads, only start "trolling" becuse of Selnor's comments. Always calling out PS3 fans or PS3 games.

That's a distinct possibility, but the way he makes threads now and doesn't even attempt to back it up with any kind of argument other than "I can't believe you don't agree with me" makes is so that even people who would leave his thread be otherwise come in here and tell him that he's being an annoyance (such as myself and naz). 

@Torrillian & Carl - I'm not saying Selnor isn't good at annoying other users I'll add, just he is in a very small minority of 360 users who hype excessively unlike the huge number in the PS3 fanbase that irritate the hell out of far more of the other console fanbases. I honestly wish we had more posters like CGI and Jagged who temper their optimism to encourage senisible debates despite their preferences!

Selnor, you're going to sprain yourself you're seeing so many titles as 'best graphics ever' recently! Take it easy. It does look very good though.

LOL. I dont bother. Because

1. It's opinion.

2. When I post a load of evidence you call it. ( Like loads of reviews stating ME2 best graphics ) People just call meh. LOL.

So whats the point. It's pretty obvious, what sgoing on. LOL.