Back in November 12, 2010, VGChartz started a little feature by the name of "Your 50 Favorite Games of All Time". The Goal was simple, to count down from November 12 to December 31 (50 days by the way) by listing our 50 favorite games of all time. Many signed up, but only around 1/3 of those who participated finished their lists (with style I may add).

Well, with enough goading (from NinPanda to be exact), I took these lists and went to work.

Here's the facts:

• 26 of you came out on December 31 (or later) with your completed lists. Well done! Let's see who made it to the goal:
  • Smeags (Oh yeah!)
  • Snfr
  • NinPanda
  • AxumBlade
  • Sapphi Snake
  • Patapon
  • ConeGamer
  • Heat
  • okr
  • Tayne
  • MilkyJoe
  • BadGenome
  • Khuutra
  • PearlJammer
  • Fredeur
  • Hikaruchan
  • Scoobes
  • Dunno001
  • 2000cc
  • AsILayHere220
  • Shogia
  • MrT-Tar
  • NonGravity
  • RaveGrunt
  • CGI-Quality
  • ForestSpirit
• 576 unique games were recorded in all. This means that each person had around 22 unique games on their lists. Thanks a lot guys, way to make me work harder than I had to...
• I'll only be counting the top 150 games in this thread. Each game was issued a numerical value based on its position. Games are also rewarded for consistancy across different member's lists. So here's how the scoring method looks:
  • Ninjabread Man got 1st place on Poster1's list! Ninjabread Man gets one point! (the fewer points the better in this case folks)
  • Ninjabread Man got 50th place on Poster2's list! Ninjabread Man gets 50 points!
  • Ninjabread Man didn't rank on Poster3's list! Ninjabread Man gets 60 points! (All games that don't rank on lists recieve 60 points as a penalty)

So there ya go! And without further notice, I present to you the top 150 games from these lists!

3 Way Tie for #150 (1478 Points):

The Curse of Monkey Island ~ Grim Fandango ~ Plants vs. Zombies

4 Way Tie for #146 (1477 Points):

Dark Cloud 2 ~ The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind ~ Mario Kart: Double Dash!! ~ Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door

2 Way Tie for #144 (1475 Points):

Spyro: Year of the Dragon ~ Terranigma

5 Way Tie for #139 (1474 Points):

Battlefield: Bad Company 2 ~ Baldur's Gate 2: Shadows of Amn ~ Super Street Fighter II ~ Tekken Tag Tournament ~ Valkyrie Profile

#138 (1473 Points):

Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes

3 Way Tie for #135 (1472 Points):

Metroid Fusion ~ Metroid: Other M ~ Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time

2 Way Tie for #133 (1471 Points):

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty ~ Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island

2 Way Tie for #131 (1469 Points):

Sid Meier's Civilization IV ~ Sonic the Hedgehog 2

#130 (1468 Points):

Dead Rising

2 Way Tie for #128 (1467 Points):

Conker's Bad Fur Day ~ StarFox 64

2 Way Tie for #126 (1466 Points):

Borderlands ~ World of Goo

3 Way Tie for #123 (1464 Points):

Duke Nukem 3D ~ Golden Sun ~ Perfect Dark

2 Way Tie for #121 (1463 Points):

Marvel vs. Capcom 2: Age of New Heroes ~ Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3 FES

2 Way Tie for #119 (1462 Points):

Disgaea: Hour of Darkness ~ Pro Evolution Soccer 5

#118 (1461 Points):

Crash Team Racing

#117 (1460 Points):

Gears of War 2

2 Way Tie for #115 (1459 Points):

Medieval II: Total War ~ Sonic the Hedgehog

2 Way Tie for #113 (1458 Points):

Chrono Cross ~ Need For Speed: Most Wanted

#112 (1456 Points):

Kingdom Hearts 2

#111 (1455 Points):

Counter Strike/Source

#110 (1454 Points):

Tales of Symphonia

2 Way Tie for #108 (1453 Points):

Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII ~ The World Ends With You

2 Way Tie for #106 (1452 Points):

Crash Bandicoot 3: Warped ~ The Legend of Zelda: Link’s Awakening

#105 (1450 Points):

Sonic and Knuckles

3 Way Tie for #102 (1449 Points):

Mario Kart Wii ~ Monkey Island 2: LeChuck’s Revenge ~ Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King

#101 (1446 Points):

Monster Hunter Tri

#100 (1444 Points):

The Secret of Monkey Island

#99 (1443 Points):

Skies of Arcadia: Legends

#98 (1442 Poitns):

Resident Evil 4: Wii Edition

#97 (1440 Points):

Bayonetta

#96 (1439 Points):

The Legend of Zelda

#95 (1438 Points):

KillZone 2

#94 (1433 Points):

Heroes of Might and Magic III

3 Way Tie for #91 (1432 Points):

Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem ~ Rome: Total War ~ Tetris

2 Way Tie for #89 (1430 Points):

Donkey Kong Country ~ Metal Gear Solid

#88 (1428 Points):

Pokemon HeartGold/SoulSilver

#87 (1426 Points):

Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction

2 Way Tie for #85 (1424 Points):

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 ~ God of War

#84 (1423 Points):

Pokemon FireRed/LeafGreen

#83 (1421 Points):

WarCraft III: Reign of Chaos/The Frozen Throne

#82 (1416 Points):

Secret of Mana

2 Way Tie for #80 (1415 Points):

Final Fantasy V ~ Metroid Prime 2: Echoes

2 Way Tie for #78 (1414 Points):

Fallout 3 ~ Halo: Combat Evolved

#77 (1412 Points):

Age of Mythology

#76 (1411 Points):

XenoGears

2 Way Tie for #74 (1410 Points):

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords ~ Tomb Raider

#73 (1406 Points):

Banjo-Kazooie

#72 (1395 Points):

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

#71 (1393 Points):

Final Fantasy X-2

#70 (1390 Points):

Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn

#69 (1389 Points):

Super Mario Kart

2 Way Tie for #67 (1385 Points):

Diablo II/Lord of Destruction ~ Psychonauts

#66 (1383 Points):

Metroid Prime 3: Corruption

#65 (1381 Points):

Earthbound

2 Way Tie for #63 (1379 Points):

Katamari Damacy ~ Ogre Battle 64: Person of Lordly Caliber

#62 (1377 Points):

Ratchet and Clank Future: A Crack in Time

#61 (1376 Points):

inFamous

#60 (1375 Points):

Assassin’s Creed II

#59 (1371 Points):

Flower

#58 (1366 Points):

Half-Life 2

#57 (1365 Points):

Age of Empires II: Age of Kings

#56 (1361 Points):

Mario Kart 64

#55 (1357 Points):

Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4

#54 (1353 Points):

Batman: Arkham Asylum

#53 (1351 Points):

God of War II

#52 (1350 Points):

StarCraft/Brood War

#51 (1349 Points):

Super Metroid

#50 (1346 Points):

Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater

#49 (1344 Points):

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night

#48 (1342 Points):

Valkyria Chronicles

3 Games Tied for #45 (1331 Points):

GoldenEye 007 ~ Pokemon Red/Blue ~ Super Smash Bros. Melee

#44 (1329 Points):

Heavy Rain

#43 (1319 Points):

Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars

#42 (1317 Points):

Super Smash Bros. Brawl

#41 (1316 Points):

Final Fantasy XII

#40 (1314 Points):

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patroits

#39 (1309 Points):

LittleBigPlanet

#38 (1307 Points):

Ico

#37 (1300 Points):

Final Fantasy VIII

#36 (1299 Points):

Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

#35 (1294 Points):

Red Dead Redemption

#34 (1292 Points):

New Super Mario Bros. Wii

#33 (1280 Points):

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

2 Games Tied for #31 (1271 Points):

Grand Theft Auto: Vice City ~ Super Mario Bros.

#30 (1270 Points):

Portal

#29 (1267 Points):

Final Fantasy IX

#28 (1262 Points):

Pokemon Gold/Silver

#27 (1258 Points):

Final Fantasy XIII

2 Games Tied for #25 (1240 Points):

Mass Effect ~ Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune

#24 (1239 Points):

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic

2 Games Tied for #22 (1236 Points):

God of War III ~ Resident Evil 4

#21 (1234 Points):

Final Fantasy VII

#20 (1211 Points):

Bioshock

#19 (1210 Points):

Okami

#18 (1208 Points):

Final Fantasy X

2 Games Tied for #16 (1205 Points):

The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask ~ Mass Effect 2

#15 (1175 Points):

The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker

#14 (1174 Points):

Super Mario World

#13 (1161 Points):

Super Mario Bros. 3

#12 (1147 Points):

Final Fantasy IV

#11 (1145 Points):

Metroid Prime

#10 (1096 Points):

Super Mario Galaxy 2

#9 (1060 Points):

The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past

#8 (1049 Points):

Shadow of the Colossus

#7 (1048 Points):

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess

#6 (1023 Points):

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

#5 (993 Points):

Super Mario Galaxy

#4 (972 Points):

Super Mario 64

#3 (967 Points):

Final Fantasy VI

#2 (963 Points):

Chrono Trigger

#1 (791 Points):

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

Links:

• 2011 Results Thread
• 2011 Official Thread
• 2011 Discussion Thread
• 2010 Results Thread
• 2010 Official Thread
• 2010 Discussion Thread

I never want to do anything like this ever again.

Ew. Heavy Rain & FFXIII.

List is unclean.

(Otherwise a good list. But could use more Mario. MOAR.)

I've just been working on this thing nonstop for the past three days. I'm tired of it, I'm tired of seeing it, I can't believe I put this amount of work in it, the excell chart is ridiculous, and I'm just sick and tired of working on it.

Give me a couple of months and I should be good to go. No way I'm doing a top 50 again though. Not on a more populated site like this. A top 20 would be better for everyone I think. Heck, 1/4 of the people who signed up didn't even finish (which I'm thankful for, 26 was enough.).

Yep... that's about it. I'm sleepy.

Oh bollocks!

I got banned half way through my list and totally forgot about it until now! Nooooooooo!

I'm sorry, Smeagsy

Good job there Smeags. Good hustle.

Gotta say I'm surprised that Ogre Battle 64 managed to outrank EarthBound, even with such a narrow margin.

You did a hell of a job, though!

Please don't! You're one less person I have to slave over.

You had Sonic in your list though, so I am kind of bummed for that. ^_~

Thank you, it means a lot to me. I'm thankful I got this done a good time before the end of the month. I couldn't even imagine getting started on the VGC Most Wanted right after this. Thinking about it makes my head hurt right now.