Thanks mZuzek for all the hard work. You're my hero, the greatest 50 games of all time is a highlight in these forums.
Some errors I noticed:
Baldur's Gate II has the subtitle Shadows of Amn, not Ann.
The GOTY's have 1981 twice.
Other than that some notes:
Yeah, Heroes of Might and Magic III is the highest ranking HOMM and in the TOP 10 for PC!
Octopath is 2018 GOTY, oh yeah!
I thought I would be the only one voting for Tokyo Mirage Sessions, I'm pleasantly surprised others have it on their lists too. Please Atlus bring it to Switch, so more people can experience this great game.