Who's the worst director of all time? | |||
| Uwe Boll | 31 | 47.69% | |
| Aaron Seltzer/Jason Friedberg | 2 | 3.08% | |
| Michael Bay | 8 | 12.31% | |
| Roland Emmerich | 1 | 1.54% | |
| Eli Roth | 0 | 0% | |
| M. Night Shyamalan | 5 | 7.69% | |
| Tom Six | 1 | 1.54% | |
| Paul W.S. Anderson | 0 | 0% | |
| Zack Snyder | 6 | 9.23% | |
| Other | 11 | 16.92% | |
| Total: | 65 | ||
Vote for Michael Bay as I don't know jsut annoys me that guy lol.
Uwe Boll never heard of him so had to look him up when I saw he was leading the poll lol
| Chrkeller said: George Lucas He didn't direct Empire and Jedi, and it shows. I-III were just trash. Last Jedi and Force were infinity better than I-III. The only movie Lucas directed that was good was Hope. |
George Lucas created the Star Wars franchise...Last Jedi and Force were the worst of the Star Wars movies..Episode 4 is and will be the best...3 was awesome in its last 20 minutes..
Last edited by Nighthawk117 - on 19 July 2019
coolbeans said:
Well, what's the real criteria here then? B/c as far as blocking, composition, visual storytelling, how to 'direct' actors, etc. Breen has none of that going for him. The 'it's so bad it's good' criteria (which I find a bit dubious with his first film) is something to consider for entertainment purposes; however, being notoriously bad would still net you in the 'worst' category. |
But, he does entertain his audience. Sure, not in the way he hoped to. Plus, I'd give it to Uwe Boll just for the fact that his movies were mainly a tax scam.
Mandalore76 said:
I think that movie would not have gotten the bad rep it has if they had not mutated a salamander and then called it Godzilla. It's definitely not Godzilla, but I wouldn't call it the worst movie I've ever seen by any stretch. |
No, it would still be a terrible movie. It's not just a bad Godzilla movie, but bad movie, period.
Rich of RLM said it best in their Half in the Bag episdode on the 2 American Godzilla films @16:37: "the 2014 movie has its issues, but what it needed to get right, it got absolutely right. This (G98) doesn't get anything right":
I wouldn't call him the worst, but Roland Emmerich has made mostly terrible films. 10,000 B.C., 2012 and Stonewall were pretty bad, too.
Uwe Boll
He directed Bloodrayne, a movie that literally gave me the urge to vomit
I am struggling to choose between the directors of Ghostbusters 2016 and The Last Jedi.
Nighthawk117 said:
George Lucas created the Fuckin Star Wars franchise...Last Jedi and Force were the worst of the Star Wars movies...Get your head out of your ass...Episode 4 is and will be the best...3 was awesome in its last 20 minutes.. |
Nobody said Lucas wasn't creative. The question is about the ability to direct or did you miss that part Mr. Magoo? And Lucas directed 1 great movie and a bunch of crap. And no, Last Jedi and Force are absolutely not the worst Star Wars movies. Episode I is literally trash and II is right behind it. III is pretty ****ing awful, but is viewed as ok because it ends with a good fight scene. Of course the fight scene is ruined by Padame literally dying of a broken heart... lol. I mean really? What was his target audience? 12 year old girls? Of course don't forget Anakin's entire downfall was because he didn't have the "high ground."....
This isn't even a discussion. If you think Force is worse than episode I-III, than you don't even have a head nor do you have a clue. Same is true with Last Jedi.
Metacritic:
Phantom: 51
Attack: 54
Revenge: 68
Force: 81
Last Jedi: 85
Not even close there scooter. The only people who don't like Last Jedi are those who don't like the most powerful person in the film being a girl. Which is sad and quite pathetic. And to be clear I am not saying Last is amazing, I'm saying it is without a doubt better than I-III. I literally can't fathom anybody thinking Phantom is better than Last.
Last edited by Chrkeller - on 19 July 2019
Chrkeller said:
Nobody said Lucas wasn't creative. The question is about the ability to direct or did you miss that part Mr. Magoo? And Lucas directed 1 great movie and a bunch of crap. And no, Last Jedi and Force are absolutely not the worst Star Wars movies. Episode I is literally trash and II is right behind it. III is pretty ****ing awful, but is viewed as ok because it ends with a good fight scene. Of course the fight scene is ruined by Padame literally dying of a broken heart... lol. I mean really? What was his target audience? 12 year old girls? Of course don't forget Anakin's entire downfall was because he didn't have the "high ground.".... This isn't even a discussion. If you think Force is worse than episode I-III, than you don't even have a head nor do you have a clue. Same is true with Last Jedi. Metacritic: Phantom: 51 Attack: 54 Revenge: 68 Force: 81 Last Jedi: 85 Not even close there scooter. The only people who don't like Last Jedi are those who don't like the most powerful person in the film being a girl. Which is sad and quite pathetic. And to be clear I am not saying Last is amazing, I'm saying it is without a doubt better than I-III. I literally can't fathom anybody thinking Phantom is better than Last. |
He directed American Graffiti and that is damn good movie.
I'll correct my stance, George Lucas hasn't directed a good movie in 42 years. And his most recent three attempts were trash.
| Chrkeller said: George Lucas He didn't direct Empire and Jedi, and it shows. I-III were just trash. Last Jedi and Force were infinity better than I-III. The only movie Lucas directed that was good was Hope. |
Revenge of the Sith is way better than you give it credit for. The Force Awakens was a beat for beat remake of A New Hope, which is why people thought it was so good. The Last Jedi was absolute garbage. I wouldn't consider either one of them better than Revenge of the Sith.
About Us |
Terms of Use |
Privacy Policy |
Advertise |
Staff |
Contact
Display As Desktop
Display As Mobile
© 2006-2024 VGChartz Ltd. All rights reserved.
