By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Religion being taught in schools

Pemalite said:

I believe students should be taught all about the different religions, their history, their contributions, their immoral acts, all of it. - It's what makes up a significant part of the world around us.

But there is a line. Once students are forced to pray every morning then a line has been crossed, it's gone from teaching to preaching and that's not okay, schools should be teaching on a fact-based basis, teach the kids about religion from a historical context backed by evidence and not some crazy mystical faith-based aspect.

I agree with this, learning about religion in school is really important, being made religious or forced to parttake in religious rituals in school is idiotic.



Around the Network

At first I thought: "Oh God, no! This is has "DISASTER" written all over it!"
While, I still have some reservations, it CAN work.
IF, and ONLY IF, all religions are taught equally and presented in a manner to INFORM, not INFLUENCE.



I agree with some users here.
Either you teach all religions equally meaning both good and bad stuff about it or you teach none. Do not favour one religion over the other.



Intel Core i7 8700K | 32 GB DDR 4 PC 3200 | ROG STRIX Z370-F Gaming | RTX 3090 FE| Crappy Monitor| HTC Vive Pro :3

monocle_layton said:

I was taught about Islam, Judaism, Christianity (several sects actually), Buddhism, Shintuism, and some ancient religions. We never had people going around screaming and trying to sue my old high school.

Same here. I, as an Agnostic, enjoyed the religion class because it was very informative.



I had to visit religion as a school topic back when I was in school. I hated it. One time I got an F because I said that I don't believe in god. I'm not kidding. At least I only had to go there while in elementary school. Later I could chose "ethics" as an alternative, where all religions were taught without trying to convert you or something. I liked that a lot more.

Today you can choose to keep your kids completely away from the christian-only religion classes here in germany. But I still think it's horrible that those classes keep existing at all. School should be all about the scientific method, in which no god has any place.



Official member of VGC's Nintendo family, approved by the one and only RolStoppable. I feel honored.

Around the Network
Ka-pi96 said:
monocle_layton said:

You'd think religion (which has a huge impact on culture and history) would be considered useful.

Nope, not really. Don't think history is that useful either. Culture can be, but you can learn about culture just fine in language or geography classes.

Failure to understand history only ensures you will repeat it again.

Jpcc86 said:
Religions shouldn't be taught in public schools. This is a secular state.

Whilst I agree to an extent, I think it's important to teach religion in a non-religious context, I.E. Not indoctrinating kids into a cult.
Whether we like it or not, Religion is entwined in our lives, Christmas, Easter, International issues, Politics... You name it.

None of my schools had religious techings... (Thank goodness for a Secular state!) But it would have been nice to have known about religion within a historical context during Social studies or History class.

OdinHades said:
I had to visit religion as a school topic back when I was in school. I hated it. One time I got an F because I said that I don't believe in god. I'm not kidding. At least I only had to go there while in elementary school. Later I could chose "ethics" as an alternative, where all religions were taught without trying to convert you or something. I liked that a lot more.

Today you can choose to keep your kids completely away from the christian-only religion classes here in germany. But I still think it's horrible that those classes keep existing at all. School should be all about the scientific method, in which no god has any place.

I failed a project in Social studies in high School because I was using wording in my project that was apparently to advanced for my age group.

I actually had to take another test to verify I could read and write on that level and get a written letter from my English teacher.

If I had a religious class and I failed that simply because I stated that God doesn't exist... I would ask my teacher to provide evidence for the existence of their particular deity as the burden of proof lays with the claimant. I.E. Them. And then take the issue farther.



--::{PC Gaming Master Race}::--

What's the problem? Religious Education/Studies is a subject in the UK school system. It teaches you about religions, what they believe and understand. This is how understanding in general is taught.

Anyone who says that religion shouldn't be taught in school doesn't understand that there is a difference between teaching a child/kid what other faiths believe and church... which is what they think is going on.



Hmm, pie.

Ka-pi96 said:
The Fury said:
What's the problem? Religious Education/Studies is a subject in the UK school system. It teaches you about religions, what they believe and understand. This is how understanding in general is taught.

Anyone who says that religion shouldn't be taught in school doesn't understand that there is a difference between teaching a child/kid what other faiths believe and church... which is what they think is going on.

Or they just think it's a waste of the kid's time and taxpayers money and they should be learning something else instead...

A better understand leads to a better world. Being ignorant about other religions... well, you know where that leads. Religions are fascinating to me, the many ideas they have formed and how it has shaped our cultures. Teaching kids about the differences and so obvious similarities between them will also make them understand other people's thinkings. It also allows them to also question the faith that might have been forced upon them as children and to make their own choice about faith.



Hmm, pie.

Pemalite said:

If I had a religious class and I failed that simply because I stated that God doesn't exist... I would ask my teacher to provide evidence for the existence of their particular deity as the burden of proof lays with the claimant. I.E. Them. And then take the issue farther

.

Yeah, that sounds good. But I was like 8 years old. xP



Official member of VGC's Nintendo family, approved by the one and only RolStoppable. I feel honored.

I don't see a problem with the video. It's the basics of the religion. Other than that either teach all religions or none except in a historical context. I agree with that sentiment. You can also make extra classes optional at some point so students can decide to learn about any religion they choose



Just a guy who doesn't want to be bored. Also