Not sure how Sony or Microsoft won. Both felt very meh to me. Best thing from Sony was Spider-Man and days gone.
Best from Microsoft was forza horizon 3 and scalebound. Not much else worth getting excited over.
Forza is an annual game, Scalebound was first shown in 2014...MS cinference was all known about and very little wow factor.
God of War? Days Gone? RE7? Kojimas trailer was impressive too. But downplay if you like. Was like this last year where all the xbox fans kept trying to push that they won something..... we all know how it is viewed in retrospect.
So your saying MS was predictable yet you mention God of War 4 which 90% of gamers knew was coming and RE7 an unnual series thats multiplat.. strange.
They were both underwhelming in my opinion, both showed many expected games. I also never judge a show using multiplats as leverage. Just like many claimed FF7 the deciding game last year yet its also coming to everything. Shows should be based on company own exclusives. They both showed similar exclusives with many 3rd party games holding up the show. Its a draw in my opinion.