By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Explain the Metacritic Gap Between Tropical Freeze and 3D World

Super Mario 3D World - 93 (highest rated Wii U game)
Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze - 82 (tied for 20th highest Wii U ranking)

 

How do you explain this gap?  Btw, user scores on Metacritic for 3D World are 8.9 and 8.8 for DKC, a much smaller gap, and everything I've seen on this site and other sites like Amazon (both have five star averages) indicate that users like DKC as much as they did 3D World.  But the critic begged to differ.  Why?  Is there a bias in favor of 3D games over 2D games?  A bias in favor of Mario games over DK games?  Or anger because Retro didn't make a Metroid game?


Around the Network

You've got it all wrong.

There was anger because these reviewers couldn't beat the game. If they can't beat it, it's dumb. (I also did notice that some reviewers would mention, "I WANTED METROID" in their reviews, although I'd hope that wouldn't sway their scores.)



I am sad to see that  critics aren't so impressed by dat  beautiful fur. :(



                
       ---Member of the official Squeezol Fanclub---

I like TF better than 3D World, so I'll say that the reviewers who rated it low, tried to send a hint to Retro "do anotha METOROIDO!!!!""

I'm happy with their choice to do TF, but would also absolutely love if they'd do another Metroid someday. No hurry though (since the general opinion here seems to be that Metroid wouldn't do jack shit to Wii U sales).

 

Edit: Also because they probably couldn't even beat the game. I love the difficulty.



Yep.

Well... I would say Mario 3d world was better than DKC just in the fun aspect imo just cause it looked better in terms of presentation and almost felt like Mario Galaxy in terms of the levels and gameplay

But probably the reason from what I can tell by reading some of the reviews was that the game was too hard and some deaths felt like trial and error sorta deaths rather than skill based deaths but idk, I didn't think that was the case but many reviewers disagree



                  

PC Specs: CPU: 7800X3D || GPU: Strix 4090 || RAM: 32GB DDR5 6000 || Main SSD: WD 2TB SN850

Around the Network

i havent played DK, but i guess Mario's brand is just too big



Revenge for not making Metroid Prime 4?



Sigs are dumb. And so are you!

User meta scores are useless, and people really didn't want retro to do a DK game again so probably feel apathetic towards it.



 

From many of the lower scored reviews it was stated that it's too hard. I find it a similar level of challenge to the old DKC's personally. A couple mentioned something about lack of variation in levels or poor designs. So far I have been pleasantly surprised by the levels, so it must just come back to personal preference with those because there doesn't seem to be any level design flaws that I have noticed, other than some are quite challenging which is what I have come to expect from DKC games.



Gotta figure out how to set these up lol.

3D world is better.

Hey that was easy.