That way they can see it wasn't the Wii audience that rejects these kinds of games. Not rail shooters, but the notion that people want to be absorbed in the games instead of playing them. If this game had been a true rail shooter, it could have worked, but as a "guided first-person experience", it turned into something they want you to watch as much as play.

EA should port Extraction to the HD systems... So it can fail?

You come across as some paranoid emo kid who feels the need to defend anything and everything Nintendo has, or does.

It's getting boring.

Oh, and no... They shouldn't. HD consoles already had the "test" game. It was called "Dead Space". That's why they are also getting "Dead Space 2".

one of the Wii's best games heading over to the HD systems? sure why not share the wealth

an on-rails shooter on HD consoles! give god of war 3 and halo reach a chance

It will probably overthrow COD as console shooting king. Or not.

"EA should port Extraction to the HD systems... So it can fail?"

So that those blaming the Wii for why the game failed can see that wasn't the reason.

"You come across as some paranoid emo kid who feels the need to defend anything and everything Nintendo has, or does."

You obviously haven't seen my post history. I criticize their mistakes. But how is this defending Nintendo? The context is about the Wii audience, which I even explicitly mention.

And the point isn't a "test game". You obviously didn't read the whole post.

The thing is, it would probably do better on ps3 and 360 then it would wii. And yes it has to do with the audience. Whatever you think of the wii, you must admit it has a large amount of kids and older people who would not be interested in extraction. The HD systems have a built in dead space fan base and thus, while extraction wouldn't burn up the sales charts on any system, it would do better on them.

It would most likely do much better. Why?

The original Dead Space was an HD game, thus its fans and audience were HD-console owners.
Also, there won't be much competition for a game like that, whereas the Wii has a plethora of rail shooters.

Valve should also bring Counter-Strike: Source to the 360 for Natal and players can make use of using their fingers as weapons :P

Oh I hope so.
It would be the only the 2nd rail shooter on the HD systems AFAIK. (1st one is Time Crisis 4 and sold 760k)