Yeah I totally forgot Oblivion ...  Morrowind was such a superior game.

uhh... yea, the point was to list games you like, but don't live up to the hype, not games you hate...

The Legand Of Zelda: Twilight Princess.

It has nice art, but the fact that the items are almost only usable in the dungeon that you find them and the empty overworld kills the game. Very good game, but the worst Zelda I have ever played.

GTA IV : After SA i was expecting...too much

COD MW 1+2: Hated the SP, the online was good but not that good

Persona 3: Good game, but not great like previous persona games

Mass Effect - Was a good game, I've beaten it 2 times, but it's nothing compared it to KOTOR. The background is nice but the game is too short and the secondary missions are not interesting.

GTA4 - Its awesome, but it gets boring after a while and because they tried to go for realism instead of the usual ridiculous fun it didn't feel like a real GTA.

Killzone 2 - Its a great game and I had a lot of fun with it, I guess it just wasn't my type of shooter though. I preferred Modern Warfare 2.

Halo 3 - the online is a whole lot of fun but I got bored of it after a while. And the single player was pretty lame.

GTA IV - decent game nothing amazing, i relly dont know how it got such high reviews having so many bugs.

Modern Warfare 2 , did not buy it but played it enough both single player and online and i just dont get it.

Lost Odyssey, dont get me wrong i enjoyed this game a lot, but people calling it the best JRPG out there are exaggerating. Plus it so cheesy i cant stand some cut scenes (when Lirium dies lol it was so bad, and that funeral bit )

Assasins Creed 1 - I love the story (Crusades are probably my favourite period in history) , characters and graphics. But the game is so flawed i couldnt fully enjoy it.
De Blob - fun but gets boring after a while

Uncharted 2
Gears of War series

Super Mario Galaxy. I just get bored when I play this, maybe jumping from planet to planet wasn't meant for Mario. On the other hand, I LOVE 2D Mario games.

Infamous. Played the demo and found it repetitive and quite boring.

Hmm, I can't think of any. If I like a game 9/10 the metacritic is about what I think it should be or it's under rated. Most games I think are over rated are games that I dislike.

I guess i'll say Fallout 3. I thought it was a good game but it was a pretty poor RPG experience. The only thing it offered imo was a cool leveling system. The storyline was crap and the only interesting characters didn't get alot of screen time or were just quest givers with no story attached to them. I think it's a B+ game overall but people talk about it like it's one of the definitive RPGs.