Now, let me make this clear immediately: This is not a thread for games you dislike. This is a thread for games that you do like, but that you still think are overrated. So for example, most people know that I don't care for MGS4. In this thread, I will not say MGS4, because I'm supposed to say games that I actually do like, but not as much as most do. Get it? Good!
For me, I'd probably have to say Okami. I think it's a fine game, but I don't think it's anywhere near as great as everyone says it is.