selnor said:
bobobologna said:
Squilliam said:
How can you say Killzone 2 has better lighting when so much of it was prebaked? |
You say this as if almost every game out there doesn't use pre-baked lighting.
@ Selnor: GameTrailers didn't say that the game looked almost as good as Uncharted 2. They said that the attention to detail is almost as good as Uncharted 2. Graphically, they said that while the game still looks stunning, "the wow factor has been quelled a bit."
EDIT: BTW, I think MW2 looks fantastic, even if the engine is showing it's age.
|
I never said GT said MW2 was as good as Uncharted 2, I said close. When a game is compared to the best graphics this gen and it's said quelled a bit. That is praise indeed. There actual words were, no other game except Uncharted 2 comes colse in attention to detail. That means no other game is as detailed as MW2 and Uncharted 2. Now yes I got the impression that GT thinks U2 is better graphically. But not by much. Thats the impression they gave. After all GT gave this for presentation scores.
MW2 = 9.8
KZ2 = 9.8
So they rate them the same.
|
No, they don't think that MW2 is almost as good looking as Uncharted 2. Attention to details does not equal graphics. It completely ignores everything about graphics including art style, polygon counts, textures, shaders, rendering techniques, etc.
If you had correctly read my post, you would have seen that I never accused you of saying that MW2 was as good looking as Uncharted 2.
And honestly, no one cares what score GameTrailers gives MW2. Giving MW2 a 9.5 and Uncharted 2 a 9.3 is a huge joke (overall scores). Not because I think Uncharted 2 is better than MW2 (haven't played MW2) but because of the reason GameTrailers used when justifying their 9.3 for Uncharted 2 (not innovative enough). Seriously, how the hell is MW2 any more innovative than Uncharted 2? GameTrailers is bullshit when it comes to scoring games. If they honestly don't think that Uncharted 2 is that great, then fine, even reviewers are allowed their own opinion. I know that it's personally not even one of my top 3 PS3 games. But don't give bullshit reasons like "lacks innovation" to cover your ass.
Excuse me for ranting about GT.
