Let me explain my experience with the Half-Life series, and maybe this helps:
I played Half-Life after it first came out. I recall the leaked OEM demo of Day 1, and how that generated a buzz. A demo spreading was said to be "illegal" but people played it anyhow. Well, I then got the game and played it. It brought to mind old adventure games, and a world that felt right and logical and real. The scene early on with the opening the gate to the other universe was creepy. It just worked for me, and was a fine point. I thought it was real good, but didn't think multi-player would amount to much. How wrong I could be. The game became a staple of the industry, giving birth to Counter Strike. The backstory was solid also.
Now, go to Half-Life 2. The art of game making is extended further. Well, at least I thought it was. It was real good, and worked, and extended further, and the game was mod friendly. It extended the reputation of Half-Life 2. Maybe now it is dated. But consider what it was when it first came out. The game added to the industry.
And then, there is The Orange Box, which is one of the best values ever. And it comes with both Team Fortress 2 and also Portal. Both of which have been praised, and Portal being considered one of the best games of this generation.
Half-Life is respected because it delivered on the expectations people had for it.