I ask 2 questions

1) Which is the better movie overall

2) Which is the better movie for HD formats.

Both make their case as they were huge movies. Blu-Ray has Spiderman exclusive.  And HD-DVD has transformers. (i think) and each format has chosen each movie respectively as the "frontrunner" to market the HD formats.

Both movies have their ridiculous moments, and at times I believe the plots fall apart. But thats not what HD movies are all about -  Right?

Any thoughts on which movie is better would be appreciated.  Anything welcome 

Serenity.

300.

Spiderman 3 was fine, but transformers was awesome.

Regarding HD formats, I don't know because I don't care about them.

Both are.

come on spider-man 3 was soooooooo boring

Transformers was OK

BUT ON HD VIDEO

SM=3 would be better

I just watched Transformers today and I sincerely wish I would have seen it in theaters. I've also seen Spiderman 3, both were great movies, however, I think giant robots kicking the shit out of each other is 100% better on High Res, huge televisions, or the big screen.

Spiderman 3 is the better movie and made more money.

As for high def, I don't know.

spiderman 3 = teh suck
transformers = teh pwn

it's as simple as that.

1. Transformers (easily)

2. Transformers. Giant Robots killing each other + HD = EPIC WIN!!!!