That's kind of like arguing that if Nintendo released a crime based sandbox game and sold it for $60 it would sell amazing because Grand Theft Auto sold so well ...

No, it due to the fact that Xbox owners aren't shy about spending $$$...It's about what level of value is being offered.  If Natal ships with a great game as Wii did with Wii Sport, I think $119 and below would deliver very healthy returns to begin with...and it's going to be during the holiday season, and after M$'s hype machine has been spinning for a while...so yeah...I do think it can emulate WiiFit sales, and no, I don't think the GTA comparison is accurate.  M$ has gotten some serious buy-in from the game development community!

The "Value" of Wii Fit didn't make it the best selling game in over a decade, Wii Fit sold so well because the software was very high quality and had unprecedented appeal with an untapped demographic of gamers.

Just matching the "Value" of Wii Fit is just like matching the "Value" of Grand Theft Auto ... Unless Microsoft can produce something truly unique and special it is very unlikely that Natal can match the success of Wii Fit.

Dunno...but I think were are in agreement here...My point is that regardless of how great Natal is...I'm not sure I'm willing to pay mroe than $119...and looking out in the marketplace for the closest example of a peripheral piece of hardware, WiiFit is the closest I could find.  M$ has done an unprecedented job of really engaging with 3rd party developers to push Natal, which will help ensure a greater level of support.  Until we actually see launch software, all of these points are tenuous, but I'm just saying that imho, anything more than $119 is pushing it.  If they have to "eat" some losses early do so, but make sure you get maximum burn on launch during the holiday season...it will immediately boost developers to look for more creative ways to push Natal....just my 2 cents.

I was really hoping I would get natal for free ....

LOL...that and XBL!

Totally! Do you think natal games will cost us anything?

Pricing is key, which will be yet another benefit for SONY's Motion Controller.

Absolutely not...lol...gamers shouldn't have to pay for anything bro...that's the cost model some think is wise!  On a serious note, I think there will be an opportunity for publisher to launch more title in the $39.99 range with Natal.

Only to a select few fans...the really hardcore ones!