By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - Uncharted 2 FIRST REVIEW by PSM3.....21/20!!!! (can this be true?)!

I personally think the 21/20 is just a figure of speech, it's a bit like stamping the 'Editor's Choice' logo on the review, except, without the logo Although I agree it's a dangerous path to take. Once you give 21/20, does it open the door to 22/20, 25/20, etc? It could render their scoring system a bit meaningless.



Around the Network
darthdevidem01 said:
MaxwellGT2000 said:

GTA4 went to 11/10 which is 110% and Uncharted 2 is 21/20 is 105%, pft as if I want to BUY THAT!

In all seriousness, any review more then their own scale AKA somehow better then perfect, is not a review to be taken seriously, Uncharted will undoubtably be a great game much like the first, hell I loved the beta, but really? A thread on a review from a unknown magazine with a broken review scale?  Does this really need to be discussed?


1. unknown magazine FOR YOU.....the two french people on this site have said this a a very credible magazine + PSM3 is known....I have heard about it before

2. Yes its important to discuss this, as not many games this gen have such a score......THE SAME mag in question gave infamous 71.

 

 

What ? Are you insane ? Only american magazines/websites matter ! OK, some reviews from UK are also fine... The rest is crap.

 

That's it, right ?



disolitude said:

Another overhyped game confirmed?

21/20 is something else though... ubber hyped game.


 Cry moar!!

 

OT - Can't wait for this game. Same magazine gave Killzone 2 8/10!!!



darthdevidem01 said:
MaxwellGT2000 said:

GTA4 went to 11/10 which is 110% and Uncharted 2 is 21/20 is 105%, pft as if I want to BUY THAT!

In all seriousness, any review more then their own scale AKA somehow better then perfect, is not a review to be taken seriously, Uncharted will undoubtably be a great game much like the first, hell I loved the beta, but really? A thread on a review from a unknown magazine with a broken review scale?  Does this really need to be discussed?


1. unknown magazine FOR YOU.....the two french people on this site have said this a a very credible magazine + PSM3 is known....I have heard about it before

2. Yes its important to discuss this, as not many games this gen have such a score......THE SAME mag in question gave infamous 71.

 

 

You answered who the hell this magazine IS but failed to answer why we should trust them with such an obviously broken scale, since one perfect game cannot be perfect +1 there is no such thing as something greater then perfect.



MaxwellGT2000 - "Does the amount of times you beat it count towards how hardcore you are?"

Wii Friend Code - 5882 9717 7391 0918 (PM me if you add me), PSN - MaxwellGT2000, XBL - BlkKniteCecil, MaxwellGT2000

Darthdevidem01: yeh slimebeast, is it not working for you either?
» its multiplayer

Marfje: Nah never mind, i meant... EU or US.. cause the EU started.. US didn't

Slimebeast1: darth, its working for me. It shows that red skirt hot chick

Darthdevidem01: lol.....well it snot working for me


lol



Time to Work !

Around the Network
ShadowSoldier said:
Smashed said:
darthdevidem01 said:
wow nothing but negativity 90% of the time so far

atleast someone could have said

"hey maybe the game is actually great"

remember the SAME PS mags have also given LAIR/Haze low scores

@susymar

either way

SMG was a HIGH calibre game

maybe thse reviews are putting Uncharted 2 into the league uncharted 1 failed to get into....that is the AAA score league

Don't you see it by now? Atleast 75% of the Sony threads made, meaning about hardware or software, gets trashed by MOSTLY 360 fanboys. 

They are jealous.

 

In The Words of The Great Jay-Z:

 

end of the story Sony followed the code/cracked the safe
360 fanboys cant play the game so they practice hate
leave the Sony fanboys alone why dont ya
you dont have to if you dont want to but dont say i didnt warn ya

 

Surely "Sony developed the code" is even cleverer...



;))

Slimebeast1: Hi all. Go to vgchartz.com and u will see the X360 is dominating in sales. I recommend Fable II, Dante's Inferno, Assassin's Creed 2, Halo ODST, Risen and Alan Wake.


lolllllll



Time to Work !

Maxwell - you really have a closed minded way of looking at this... what a review is suppose to do is rate how much fun the player had with the game... How does numbers translate that?



CGI-Quality,


it is Slimebeast making Xbox360 free advertising on the Unchatred2 beta live site lol

(justin.tv)



Time to Work !

kowenicki said:
seriously.. this does start a dangerous trend... it could just break the review system (even more than it already is)


dude no it doesn't, they gave GTA:SA a 21/20 5 YEARS AGO

so whats changed now?

5 years later they have given another game 21/20

_________-

21/20 probably means it EXCEEDS all current offerings on platforms

___________

@Maxwell

Why should we trust the scale?

well seeing their past review scores make sme trust it

they gave GTA:SA 21/20......thats in my top 5 of all time..

they gave infamous 71/100......I too found the game quite average....not bad at all though

in 2 cases I am agreeing with their reviews (2 means nothing in the huge scheme of things)......so for me its a good indication of Uncharted 2's quality

I can't say why anyone else can trust it, but getting the general meaning from the scale is important.........for me its shouting out Uncharted 2 is a brandishingly awesome game

 



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey