By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Last Guardian E3 Trailer: Is It Really In-Game?

 

Source:www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-last-guardian-e3-blog-entry

Yes, there's no doubt we're late to the party with coverage of The Last Guardian's E3 trailer, but we really wanted a high quality video asset to work with before we analysed it in-depth. The results are somewhat intriguing, and the decision to wait was the right one, but even now there's still an element of uncertainty about what it is exactly that we're looking at.

First off, our general impressions. The chances are they're probably the same as yours: there's no doubt whatsoever that this is a trailer is a wonderful piece of work, and it succeeds mostly because of an ethos that we've seen elsewhere in Sony first party projects, in particular Killzone 2. While the basic magnificence speaks for itself, all console hardware has inherent technical limitations (in short, something has to give) but the impact of those compromises in-game can be lessened through the expert handling of art and tech in concert. So with that in mind, here's the lowdown on what Sony revealed during E3.

 

Click the source to watch The Last Guardian trailer, with the customary technical annotations.(Don't know how to embed)

www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-last-guardian-e3-blog-entry

 

The cinematic style of the whole trailer makes it difficult to pick up what might be gameplay and what might be cut-scenes, but what is curious is that some scenes appear to have anti-aliasing, while others have none at all. Some scenes are confirmed 720p, while others - due to the compression of the video asset - are much more difficult to discern. Adding further to the confusion is the emergence of screenshots on one of our favourite overseas sites, the Korean Ruliweb.

There is the strong possibility that what we have here doesn't actually feature any gameplay at all, and similar to the original God of War 3 reveal video, is a purpose-built trailer using actual assets from the development but with no in-game action. An alternative is that the trailer is cut together with video taken from the game at various stages of development, which has some plausibility to it bearing in mind the existence of the older video that was leaked pre-E3.

Regardless, there's obviously something special here, but until code is in the wild, or good quality direct feed capture of actual gameplay becomes available, consider this analysis tentative and somewhat incomplete.

 

 

If posted already please lock the thread.



Around the Network

Team ICO doesn't do CGI trailers. And those screenshots do have AA, like all good promotional screenshots (Shadow of the Colossus, anyone?)



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

"Meh" is my comment to trying to assess paintings by weighting them. Basically who cares if the trailer was pre-rendered in-engine and then processed?
I'm ready to bet that the antialiasing or the resolution are not what awed whoever was touched by that video.



"All you need in life is ignorance and confidence; then success is sure." - Mark Twain

"..." - Gordon Freeman

It's polished in game footage.

You think they'd work three years just to show some CGI movie ? I don't believe a word of this.



Team ICO doesn't do CGI...they work hard on there engines



Around the Network

Its the ingame engine...

And parts of the trailer looked like gameplay.



                            

its cgi like many ps3 footages.



its in game engine you can easily tell.

plus it contains some actual gameplay footage also.



...not much time to post anymore, used to be awesome on here really good fond memories from VGchartz...

PSN: Skeeuk - XBL: SkeeUK - PC: Skeeuk

really miss the VGCHARTZ of 2008 - 2013...

It looks like a mix of cutscenes and gameplay...

Looks really good too



Proud Member of GAIBoWS (Gamers Against Irrational Bans of Weezy & Squilliam)

                   

lol at people thinking it has in-game footage.

Read the 2nd last part in the OP article:

"There is the strong possibility that what we have here doesn't actually feature any gameplay at all, and similar to the original God of War 3 reveal video, is a purpose-built trailer using actual assets from the development but with no in-game action."


So, sorry people, but The Last Guardian won't look as fantastic as in that trailer.
(remember there's usually a big quality difference between in-engine cut-scenes and in-engine game-play - that's an easy thumb of rule for the majority of games)

But If the trailer indeed was in-game, then that would easily be the new graphics king on the PS3 - and anyone who disagrees must buy new glasses, because Uncharted II and KZ2 dont look anywhere near as good as TLG trailer's grafix.