I LOVE it. It is the golf game we always wanted on work.

It just works!!

Especially putting which was always a problem, now feels completely natural.

And inclusion of Disc (frisbee) Golf is awesome! Even if you don't care for a golf sim itself the game is worth it for just Disc Golf and the party game modes.

Plus you'll save on the cost of WM+ too.

Neither have I. I agree!

I have to disagree with you there. 

while the disc golf is somewhat realistic, the physics seem a bit wonkey to me at times.  If you throw a tomahawk/hammer style (as I often do for approach shots in disc golf) the disc doesnt flip like it does in real life.  Furthermore, you cant create an S curve from what i've seen, which kind of puts a damper on tee shots.  Collision detection is also spotty at times, with weird bounces and little to no rolling, which is also kind of a bummer because I like to play the roll.

That said, its still great fun, and your fidelity of control is pretty damn amazing, if not unrealistic at times.

Yeah, IGN noted that Disc Golf seemed amazingly authentic, until you played Frisbee in Wii Sports Resort which has better physics behind it and then you notice the difference.   But it's still great fun and a fantastic addition.

Eh?

What does throwing hammer style mean? I would assume vertical? (ie if you have the disc flat in front of you, tip it 90^ clockwise)
I obviously don't use frisbees a lot but I would think if you throw it like that it just goes straight to ground.

I guess I am missing the meaning of tomahawk/hammer style, or there is some technique I am unfamiliar with (my frisbee experiences involve getting it to go in a straight line)

Wow... i wish EA sports would show the same effort for all the sports games, especially FIFA =\

Given the reviews, I am almost ready to go out and get this game -- which I had no desire to buy before the reviews.

Notice the places the game got nicked -- graphics and music -- exactly the places where it cannot, by definition, live up to the same standards as the HD consoles. But it sounds like other than that this is a superior version.

Mike from Morgantown

Yes, it means throwing it overhand, not neccesarily from 90 degrees though; (more like anywhere from 60 degrees to 120 degrees, depending on when you want it to flip).  This video is dark, but is the best example and explanation of it... the throw itself is not til the very end, about the 1:30 mark:

Its called "thumbing" if you throw it with the flat part of the disc facing the other end.  Here's an example of the S curve too... the best throw is the third one in the video @ 37 seconds in.  It curves right for a long distance then flexes back left...

I'm interested to see if Wii Sports Resort get the physics accurate enough for throws like these.  Playing disc golf at TPC Sawgrass is certainly cool enough to make up for the subpar physics in TW though.  I cant wait to get home and play another 18 of both Disc golf and a tourney on my tour.

The S-curve looks pretty neat.... does it need wind to do something like that?

As for the tomahawk thing.... tbh it just looked like he chucked it vertically, If I could see properly I wouldn't be suprised if it cut into the ground where it landed.

As for the videos in general, I didn't even realise disc-golf was a real sport.

Nope, you dont need wind to make it flex--the disc bends that way naturally with airflow from your throw.

And yes, disc golf is one of the fastest growing sports in the world, and there are tournaments pros and amatuers, everything just like in regular golf. 

Haha, i actually just checked www.PDGA.com and Tiger Woods Wii is on the front page of that site right now.

Also, if anybody gets inspired by TWii 2010, and wants to play real disc golf, you can find if there are any courses in your area from here:

http://www.pdga.com/course-directory?s=92ed251cc74700dcfdad109bef1285cd