First of all, Zen, I love your posts. You tend to bring a lot of hate down on yourself, but you're totally right. My Xbox 360 is the first console I've owned since the SNES. Before the SNES and NES I was a PC gamer and in between the SNES and the 360 I was a PC gamer. It killed me to go back to consoles, but after becoming a dad I couldn't justify the time and money involved with PCs anymore. That being said, I'm a console gamer more out of necessity. I don't feel like fussing with my PC so much anymore, but I HAVE to game on something. So I picked the cheaper and more common-among-my-friends console on the market. Other than that, I have no emotional attachment to the 360. And if the 360 ended up being in third place, I honestly wouldn't care. I am always so backed up on games I haven't finished yet, I will never run out of things to play.
So I feel I'm looking at what you're saying without the fanboy goggles on, and you are absolutely right. The PS3 doesn't suck, and I would love to have one just for Little Big Planet and a couple of other games, but the fact is that the console is too expensive and BluRay doesn't appeal to me one bit. We have now officially entered the age of on demand HD movie content, either via PayPerView, streaming Netflix, Xbox Live, PSN, whatever you prefer. There are some people out there who like collecting movies and owning as many as they can, so there is a necessity for movies to be on discs, but not nearly as much as there used to be. If you don't collect movies for the sake of collecting them, who needs a BluRay player? (And yes, I know people are going to argue that you have a limited window to watch pay per view movies. To those people, I say "Get a DVR. Problem solved.")
And finally, to those of you who think that PSN is free...........indirectly, it's really not: http://g4tv.com/thefeed/blog/post/694179/Sony-Charging-Publishers-to-Host-DLC-Uh-Oh.html
Sony may not be charging you for online services that Xbox Live does charge you for, but they are charging the developers for things that they shouldn't be, therefore possibly discouraging them from adding content to PSN. Furthermore, I think if anything, NXE has caused a decrease in how many ads I feel that I'm seeing on the dashboard (The blades were more ad friendly, and on NXE I feel like I rarely see an ad at all) while I think that if/when HOME finally hits its prime, it will be a major ad-fest. There will be whole rooms on HOME that are just big giant ads. It may be free to go in, but I encourage you not to fall for it.
Anyway, just some observations. I don't hate the PS3. I wouldn't turn down a free one, and if it were $100 cheaper at the beginning I may have even considered buying one instead of a 360. I wouldn't have minded if they had to leave out the BluRay or the backwards compatibility to decrease the cost. I just want to play games.