Shadow of the Colossus (relax, just kidding. One of my all time favourites)

Hmm. Wow, it's a lot easier to think of underrated games than overrated ones.

I would go with Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers. It was painful. It didn't deserve more than a 3.

Gta: Vice City. It didn't feel like the 80's at all!! I liked Gta lll and San Andreas, but Vice City was a glitchy mess.

 I have to agree with you. Underrated:

Amplitude

Frequency

Haunting Ground

I forgot another overrated game: Final Fantasy X-2.

The sword shows you where to go to get to the bosses, but besides that part of the game is exploration.  SotC is a fantastic game.  Some bosses were frustrating until I realized what to do, but I enjoyed that a lot more than doing stupid puzzles to unlock a door like you have to do with most games.  I didn't have problems with framerate, either.

Final Fantasy XII, Devil May Cry 1(DMC1 was a good game, but hardly as amazing as people claim).

 Dude its a bunch of fuckin disney characters. Its overrated as hell.

lmao!! what a way to put it bluntly. :P

God of War, I hate that shit game.

I wouldn't worry about coolestguyever, not only is he a certified cocksucker, but his choice of games blows as hard as he does.

KH1. It's a joke of a game... KH2 nails it in every aspect possible, gameplay and characters especially. Not to mention artstyle... the beauty that is The World That Never Was...

I don't understand how can ANYONE put KH1 above KH2. I also don't understand how the hell anyone enjoys this.