I liked both games.

Have no problem with X-2; if it wasn't as good as X, well, that's no big crime.

Short answer: not even close. Long answer will be in my next post.

I liked them both, for different reasons.

The games don't play alike at all, it's a bit hard to compare... I do think both games are underrated, though. Nobody appreciates FFXII because it's too different from a normal FF, and everyone hates on FFX-2 because it didn't take itself seriously (it's a hard game to defend, I'll say that much).

eh i loved X-2 in its own way but it dissapointed me BIG time my first play through. the second time around when i looked at it as the quirky Japanese targeted rpg it was i enjoyed it much more. while many don't agree with me FFX was my second favorite in the series so i had really high expectations

i personally enjoyed FFXII much more

FFX-2 is absolutely fantastic.

Great graphics, good battle system, love the heroines, love the cast, love the multiple endings... and 1000 words is a great song!

Maybe it's the FFX fan speaking in me, but I do not regert beating it 3 times... I enjoyed every moment of it.

I haven't played FFX-2, but FFXII was fantastic! I will fight about it.

FFX-2... I'm a girl and I thought it was too pink and bubbly but to be fair I guess it had some good moments too. I loved the jobs and battle system.

Can't say I played FFXII much... I don't feel like playing it that much cause o all the negativity around the game. I'll have to at some point though.

I have not played X-2. But FFXII is the best FF game I have. It's amazing, great, epic and incredibly well done. I havent played a single jRPG game that comes close to how good was FFXII.

FFXII is a disgrace to the FF franchise, how I loath that game, it's the only FF game I have only played one, I barely manage that.

How about they are both horrible, horrible, horrible and X-2 edges XII just a little bit on the horrible scale (since I stopped playing before I stopped playing XII)?

They were awful. My God, awful