How much would it sell and would it pass PS3 version's sales.

Didn't we drop this subject a while ago?

Well, I guess it's time for this rumor to start up again.

Probably BioShock on PS3 numbers. Maybe a little better, but everybody who wants to play this probably already has.

...I would say about 400k first week.

It depends.

Same day release: 2.5 million
Release next week: 1 million
Release on 12th June 2009: 200k.

But it's not happening.

shud do ok over a million............definitive version is already out............i think mgs4 will b out on 360 next year.............exclusives only stay exclusives unless its direct 1qst party or moneyhatted dev on 3rd party............ie gaiden2 microsoft moneyhatted it completly so it will never come to ps3............mgs4 is exclusive but exclusivity runs out after 12wmonths at most ie sonata, bioshock etc

if it had come out same time... 2.5-3 mil..... now maybe 1 to 1.75..... the ps3 would still be the better selling platform

I'm not sure but i think it could reach 1m

No idea, depends on the line-up ta the realease moment but at least 1.5 millions.

Anyhow, If it becomes a reality, well, I'll do my part !!

yep.. basically what Kantor wrote...