"Look MS wants to be profitable with the Xbox 360 and any thought of a 2009 release of a new consoles is foolishness."
"Based on this roadmap I would expect a new Xbox not earlier than EOY 2012 - 4 years from now."
Well, then don't expect a new Gears game until then either as Epic will want it on the Nextbox to show off what they can do with the next UT engine, and they really pushed the 360 as far as it can go with Gears 2. So what game is going to help the 360 to reach that 100 million mark you folks are speculating about here? Only two games have ever shown the ability to move xbox consoles and as I pointed out with one of those being on its decline and the other being postponed 'till 2012 0r 2013 as you say, 360 sales just won't pick up enough to reach that mark. It would be at 50,000 ltd at the end of its run.
"During 2009 Microsoft will sell 11M units of 360 and will reach 40M installed base no later than then the end of Q1 2010.
Sony will sell no more than 9M units during 2009."
Sony will whip the 360 in 2009, 2010 and beyond. Starting in January 2009, the PS3 library of games will be the most prestigious on the market until the release of the next round of consoles and the only two games on any console that will rival what Sony will be bringing to the market are the next Mario and Zelda games to be released on the Wii in 2010. In the mean time without games like Gears of War with Halo on its downward spiral, and with most of the 360's heavy hitters having been released on the market during the last two years and most of their attempts at original IP's turning out to be disappointments (Too Human, Ninja Gaiden II, Infinite Undiscovery, etc) the 360 will start to stagnate like the Genesis in its latter years. The 3 most hyped games for the 360 during the next year Halo: Recon, Halo Wars, and Alan Wake will almost certainly do no better than an 88, an 85 to 87, and somewhere in the 70's respectively in their Game Rankings scores, and I expect none of the other titles that they would bring out (if you check the names of the studios making 360 exclusives during the next year, very few of them have any history at all in the games arena) will fare no better. Rare is certainly not a developer to look to for help as the highest reviewed game that they've been able to come out with in their last five tries is an 85. And that wasn't even for their last game.
So Microsoft has two choices. Not bring out a new xbox console until 2012, as some of you say, keep on going as they are and just let Sony catch up and pass them over the next year to year and a half while waiting till 2012 to bring out a new console.
Or they could follow the path that has brought them so much success this gen -- roughly the same path they were on during the transition from the original xbox to the 360. They know that the next Nintendo console is going to be no more powerful in respect to the current 360 or PS3 than the Wii is to last gen consoles, so they can get to work on their next super machine now. Announce it for release some time in 2009 or 2010 and have Gears of War 3 be the game that justifies its purchase at the price tag it will undoubtably carry.
Such a new system and announcement of Gears 3 would be able to mitigate a great deal of the thunder that otherwise the PS3's library of games will have for the next few years.
A 3rd option would be to bring out Gears 3 on the 360 in 2010. It would really not show any more improvements in design, graphics, etc than Gears 2 at that time. It would basically lead to a downward spiral for the Gears series much like the one the Halo series is on; then try to sell a $600.00 system in 2012 with no strong title to justify large sales for such an expensive system.
My most anticipated games: Whatever Hideo Kojima is going to do next, Final Fantasy XIII, Final Fantasy Versus XIII, Gran Turismo 5, Alan Wake, Wii Sports Resort. Cave Story Wiiware.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqqLMgbtrB8