I kinda agree with all except for LBP and maybe Sonic Chronicles.

me too,and maybe sonic unleahed(maybe)

 In Mario you can collect coins, stomp enemies transform and you have a  purpose rescue Peach.

I understand their gripe about LBP and it's been the same one I've been having.

That said, I probably will pick the game up but that's only because I'm confident in my abilities to make something fun and confident in my friends abilities to make something fun. I'm totally not confident in the communities abilities to keep me entertained. I'm expecting penis level after penis level actually.

i think they said that LBP will also have enemies

hmm so LBP is pretty much like a upgraded Incredible machine game??

Oh boy I am getting old this reminds me of the old days..

This reminds me of people who thought Counter Strike would fail because you have to kill the terrorist/Anti-Terrorists over again ;..

Not really. LBP is a platformer, and an incredibly stripped-down one at that, albeit with a nifty physics engine and graphical style. From what we've seen in the videos, the only actions your sackboys are capable of are "jump" and "grab." Most quality NES platformers were more fully-featured.

Therefore, what people seem to be expecting is that the user-created levels will somehow make it better.  However, while the hardcore gaming community seems to go crazy over anything that includes user-generated content, said user-generated content usually sucks unless the game garners a wide enough audience to attract people with enough time to dedicate to make it not suck. (See: Neverwinter Nights.) Given the PS3's userbase, and that userbase's attraction to gritty, realistic graphics, we'll most likely never see anything near the quality of some of the better user-created NWN scenarios.

Besides transforming (to my knowledge), you can do all those things in LBP.  Right down to having Peach at the end of the level.

Agree with everyhting but LBP.. what the fuck man...