im same as the OP, inverted on consoles and non-inverted on pc's. i think there's something wrong with me...

inverted

Inverted is my preference, though I can get used to abnormal.

Of course Wii remote is normal.... I wouldn't be suprised if I started trying to point the controller at the screen when in an old FPS..... When I tried Mario Kart Wii with the GC controller I kept trying to flick up to wheelie. And when I tried to play F-Zero X (VC) I was leaning the GC controller to steer.

Inverted on consoles is the way to go, normal on PC.

I even use inverted on GTAIV

Inverted all the way :D does that mean I'm unco?

inverted, the only way :)

Normal ... I only use inverted in flight sims :)

Normal all the way...

I only play dual analog FPS, since I'm a computer n00b and don't have a desktop.

Normal on PC inverted on Consoles...

Ditto.  Once you've been playing it that way for about 30 minutes it's fine.

If I have to pick one then I'll go with normal for FPS (inverted for flight sims).