Straight for the poll. They seem to me as action games but people call them RPG's. What say you?
The Norse GoW games are... | |||
| RPG's | 2 | 12.50% | |
| No RPG's | 10 | 62.50% | |
| Somewhere in the middle | 4 | 25.00% | |
| I can't decide | 0 | 0% | |
| Total: | 16 | ||
Straight for the poll. They seem to me as action games but people call them RPG's. What say you?
No. Simple skill trees do not make a rpg.
GOAT: GTA6
Highest Rated Ever + Record Sales
No, while you are roleplaying as Kratos, there aren't many choices to be made. It is closer to a Zelda game than an RPG.
It depends how you to define RPGs. Under strict definitions it is not, but under those same definitions pretty much all JRPGs would also not be an RPG.


There are some elements of a RPG, mainly the stats on your gear and weapons.
Signature goes here!
| DekutheEvilClown said: It depends how you to define RPGs. Under strict definitions it is not, but under those same definitions pretty much all JRPGs would also not be an RPG. |
Lol. Yeah, they wouldn't but you're still playing a roll. I don't think GoW are RPGs but where is the line drawn and cast. Elements of RPG's yes but on this second thread now it's the same, everyone has their own image of what an RPG is and noone can define it. Someone broke it down in the TW3 thread but still weren't able to make a defined outline of what an RPG is without breaking it down to sub genres.
| TruckOSaurus said: There are some elements of a RPG, mainly the stats on your gear and weapons. |
Yeah. It had RPG elements. That's probably the best that can be said about it.
They are action games with some small traditional rpg elements to them.
Wow, I was not expecting somewhere in the middle to be thing in the poll. They have only slight upgrade elements, no different than other recent action games. Kinda exciting though, cause the definition of RPG is so widely varied between people.
Role. Playing. Game.
Role play.
Do you play a role?
Do you have agency in how to build that role?
Do you have choices within the role?
can you effect the world or characters/story with those choices?
Do you have freedom to make that role harder or easier?
Do you have choice in both above or other areas?
If so, it's a role playing game. GoW isn't in between either cause it only has choice in gear stats. What else does it have to make it an RPG? It's a storied action game with gear stats.
Jesus, I'd hate to ask this forum if Diablo is a cRPG or hack and slash.