By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Suppose Your Favorite Gaming Franchise Hits It Big…

Think like Animal Crossing or Red Dead Redemption big: its latest entry has sold tens of millions at full price, and now has a massive online community. How would you feel? Surely that means your favorite franchise is guaranteed to receive care and attention from the devs… but is that really worth it if that just leads to, for instance, needing to wait an entire decade for some AAA cinematic experience? Plus your once niche interest has become mainstream. Though perhaps the more, the merrier?

Give me your thoughts.



Around the Network

Depends; if a series I love that is niche, such as say Starfox or Xenoblade, made it big in a way that retained the things I loved about it, then I'd be happy.

However, the risk here is that broadening an IP's reach to appeal to a mainstream audience often means dumbing it down for the masses, and in the process losing the qualities that make it great.

Regarding dev times, anything over 5 years is too much IMO.



It finally did, with Breath of the Wild.



Beath of the Wild made my favorite franchise hit it big.



Fuck no.

It's equivalent of that modern curse "I hope your favorite book gets adapted by Netflix".



Around the Network

They did. It's called World of Warcraft and the rest of the series died as a result.

(But I love WoW so I'm not too mad)



Try out my free game on Steam

2025 OpenCritic Prediction Leagues

Does it stay true to what the series is? If Yes then awesome for me as more entries. Does it get AAA'd and dumbed down with a bunch of shit AAA gaming cliches and writing? if Yes, I rather it be dead. I watched Star Trek die. Star Trek abandoned everything that made it and turned into complete trash to appeal to people who don't like Star Trek. So I abandoned it.



Bite my shiny metal cockpit!

Chrono Trigger. If a new entry was released and it hit it big i would be immensely surprised by that fact alone. I dont think Square would know what to do with a series like that tbh, probably wont even let it keep its identity. Everything non-FF and non-DQ is done very generic by them, and sometimes even those franchises fall to generic tropes as well.

Last edited by Louie_86 - on 19 October 2026

This already happened with Final Fantasy 7.  It's been a hell of a roller coaster ride ever since.



Like others here, I do really like Zelda, and was very happy when it blew up with BOTW, as I consider it to be one of the best games ever made.