I'm saddened that KotOR only garnered 2 votes so far.

Resident Evil 4 gets my vote. Perfection.

This is a hell of a contest.  Half of the games in the poll have enough votes, that they still have a decent shot at winning.

I've never even played it.  (Hell, I've never even owned an XBox of any generation.)  It is one of those games I'd like to try at some point though.

Not sure if PC is your thing at all, but in case it is and you just didn't know, there's a PC version as well. I imagine almost anything is able to run the game at this point since it's so old.

I think it's the case of being OG XBOX/PC exclusive, so a lot of people never played it, which is a shame. I always found it great game that can appeal to both WRPG and JRPG audience.

Yeah, this is about what was happening in my head when I was trying to decide my vote (though I'm surprised for no love of Twilight Princess) - I can make a case for almost any of those games, and then make a ", but..." statement in the same sentence.

Same.  Must've been me and you. lol

Yep I guess we can hold hands.

Needless to say I’d recommend it.

Still a close race between RE4 and Super Mario Galaxy, HL2 sadly falling behind.

Any voters left?

Galaxy deserves it. Most perfect game ever made.