By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - SMG is giving me carpal tunnel

^Playing anything standing up in gamestop is uncomfortable though. If you played it at home, you wouldn't have any problems.



Around the Network
DMeisterJ said:
Neos said:
ecurbj said:
I played it at Gamestop for about 25 minutes and got completely turned off by the fact my hands couldn't rest anywhere.

On a conventional controller you could rest your arms on your knees while in a sitting position, but standing up with a Wii-mote you have to always have your arms pointing out and that can have a negative impact on me.

When I get my Wii I will be using it for my friends and sisters, for multiplayer action only. My sisters can do what they want with it for all I care.

Just for me I like the conventional controller better (X360, PS3).

 so when you sit down, you can't play the wii??

and, you can't rest your arms on your knees while having the wii mote controller in your hand?

I see, Ignorance is a bliss.


You can sit down, but it's a lot harder to do lots of movement with your arms how we play.  

I play with ecurbj all the time over his house and whatnot, and we sit hunched forwared, resting our elbows on our knees, and I've played a little bit of Zelda on the Wii, and sitting how we sit when we play Halo is just not possible.  And I don't think I could play SMG sitting down either, but that's just my $0.02

And Neos, don't call ecurbj ignorant, he's anything but.


Right you can't play the Wii sitting down. I think you remember when I was over your crib, and we were playing Resident Evil: Umberlla Chronicles. For the love of gosh, I was standing right in front of the TV screen and the sensor bar couldn't pick up on my Wii-Mote. So I had to back up a couple of feet and just found out on to shoot, after about 15 minutes of play my arms got tired and I just dropped the Wii-mote and left. 

Neos, I'm not bashing the Wii, I'm seriously backing up my claims against it. As I get use to the console, when I get a Wii. Maybe my claims will change, but going over my peeps cribs and playing it. I sense that it's a totally different experience than with a conventional controller via X360, PS3.



DMeisterJ said:
 

You can sit down, but it's a lot harder to do lots of movement with your arms how we play.

I play with ecurbj all the time over his house and whatnot, and we sit hunched forwared, resting our elbows on our knees, and I've played a little bit of Zelda on the Wii, and sitting how we sit when we play Halo is just not possible. And I don't think I could play SMG sitting down either, but that's just my $0.02

And Neos, don't call ecurbj ignorant, he's anything but.


I really don't understand that at all. The way that you play that you described is exactly how I play all the time. Hunched over, resting my hands/elbows on my knees.

People are getting way too confused, possibly when they see Nintendo's ads of people standing and playing. Like I said earlier I don't stand for anything but GH and Wii Sports. RE4, Trauma Center, SMG, SSBB, Zelda: TP, SvR, Madden, MoH:H2, and MP3 are all games i've played sitting down resting comfortably and i've never felt awkard or uncomfortable.

Edit: just saw the post about RE:UC, haven't played that myself but using the arcade mode in MOH:H2 I had no problem sitting down.  I'm guessing your sensor bar setup isn't ideal and is why you are thinking that standing is a neccessity.  Once you get it set up properly you can sit down and relax just like a "traditional" controller. 



epsilon72 said:
^Playing anything standing up in gamestop is uncomfortable though. If you played it at home, you wouldn't have any problems.

I played the Wii at my cousin's house (DMeisterJ). And he knows how I felt about the Wii. When I was over there I played Wii Sports, Resident Evil: Umbrella Chronicles.

Some awesome games by the way. But for me the Wii-mote was different to grasp then others because I for one am not use to it. Unlike some rabid fanboys who love Nintendo will defintely find ways to get use to it in like 20 minutes and say its a awesome experience.

And to tell you the truth the Wii-mote is awesome itself. Maybe once I get one I can pass judgement on the experience. I'm more like telling you a personal experience from me playing it over a peeps house.



azrm2k said:
DMeisterJ said:
 

You can sit down, but it's a lot harder to do lots of movement with your arms how we play.

I play with ecurbj all the time over his house and whatnot, and we sit hunched forwared, resting our elbows on our knees, and I've played a little bit of Zelda on the Wii, and sitting how we sit when we play Halo is just not possible. And I don't think I could play SMG sitting down either, but that's just my $0.02

And Neos, don't call ecurbj ignorant, he's anything but.


 I really don't understand that at all.  The way that you play that you described is exactly how I play all the time.  Hunched over, resting my hands/elbows on my knees.  

People are getting way too confused, possibly when they see Nintendo's ads of people standing and playing.  Like I said earlier I don't stand for anything but GH and Wii Sports. RE4, Trauma Center, SMG, SSBB, Zelda: TP, SvR, Madden, MoH:H2, and MP3 are all games i've played sitting down resting comfortably and i've never felt awkard or uncomfortable.


You play like that in games that use the sensor bar?  

Cause whenever I had to use the bar in Zelda, I had to change how I was sitting.



Around the Network

You can execute a spin with a nunchuk shake as well, if you find spreading the waggle helps you cope.

The camera only bothered me very rarely. I just put it down to the fact that this game is incredibly 3D in ways that no other game I've played has been. I mean, most games do bind you to to a mostly 2D playfield, simply because gravity works that way.

And people who can't play Wii while sitting baffle me. Just rest the wrist of your wiimote-holding hand on your knee to stabilize the pointer and put your nunchuk hand wherever feels comfortable. If you don't need IR, you can leave a hand at either side for total slackness.


Edit: Oh yes, and there are quite a few titles that use the D-pad for camera control. SMG does let you use it under certain condiitions, but Godfather, Okami, and No More Heroes use it for camera all the time.


"The worst part about these reviews is they are [subjective]--and their scores often depend on how drunk you got the media at a Street Fighter event."  — Mona Hamilton, Capcom Senior VP of Marketing
*Image indefinitely borrowed from BrainBoxLtd without his consent.

ecurbj said:
epsilon72 said:
^Playing anything standing up in gamestop is uncomfortable though. If you played it at home, you wouldn't have any problems.

I played the Wii at my cousin's house (DMeisterJ). And he knows how I felt about the Wii. When I was over there I played Wii Sports, Resident Evil: Umbrella Chronicles.

Some awesome games by the way. But for me the Wii-mote was different to grasp then others because I for one am not use to it. Unlike some rabid fanboys who love Nintendo will defintely find ways to get use to it in like 20 minutes and say its a awesome experience.

And to tell you the truth the Wii-mote is awesome itself. Maybe once I get one I can pass judgement on the experience. I'm more like telling you a personal experience from me playing it over a peeps house.

didn't know u were cousins with DMeisterJ

OT: Wonder if Ninty expected these type of problems. lol 

 



azrm2k said:
DMeisterJ said:
 

You can sit down, but it's a lot harder to do lots of movement with your arms how we play.

I play with ecurbj all the time over his house and whatnot, and we sit hunched forwared, resting our elbows on our knees, and I've played a little bit of Zelda on the Wii, and sitting how we sit when we play Halo is just not possible. And I don't think I could play SMG sitting down either, but that's just my $0.02

And Neos, don't call ecurbj ignorant, he's anything but.


I really don't understand that at all. The way that you play that you described is exactly how I play all the time. Hunched over, resting my hands/elbows on my knees.

People are getting way too confused, possibly when they see Nintendo's ads of people standing and playing. Like I said earlier I don't stand for anything but GH and Wii Sports. RE4, Trauma Center, SMG, SSBB, Zelda: TP, SvR, Madden, MoH:H2, and MP3 are all games i've played sitting down resting comfortably and i've never felt awkard or uncomfortable.

Edit: just saw the post about RE:UC, haven't played that myself but using the arcade mode in MOH:H2 I had no problem sitting down.  I'm guessing your sensor bar setup isn't ideal and is why you are thinking that standing is a neccessity.  Once you get it set up properly you can sit down and relax just like a "traditional" controller. 


I pretty sure you had to least pick your arm up off your knees just to point and click to get to somewhere else on the screen. It's rather tedious. And I watched my cousin play Zelda for a couple of minutes and noticed he had to move around alot just to get himself comfortable.

Just plain and simple your arms can get tired.



rocketpig said:

Seriously, this game is f***ing up my wrist with all the shaking. I thought my years of chronic masturbation had worked out these sorts of problems but apparently I was wrong. I can play it for about 2 hours before it starts hurting badly enough to stop.

Has anyone else had this problem with this game? I have played plenty of other Wii games but this is the only one that is giving me fits like this.


Swing your arm, not your wrist.



famousringo said:
You can execute a spin with a nunchuk shake as well, if you find spreading the waggle helps you cope.

The camera only bothered me very rarely. I just put it down to the fact that this game is incredibly 3D in ways that no other game I've played has been. I mean, most games do bind you to to a mostly 2D playfield, simply because gravity works that way.

And people who can't play Wii while sitting baffle me. Just rest the wrist of your wiimote-holding hand on your knee to stabilize the pointer and put your nunchuk hand wherever feels comfortable. If you don't need IR, you can leave a hand at either side for total slackness.

I will try that out, never thought of it that way. Maybe its the ads that Nintendo presents makes me think what I think. Maybe I always thought Nintendo required you to stand and move your arms around like gestures to get the full experience.

idk, but I will use that technique for future reference, bro.