By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Best second console

 

I think the best is...

SNES 34 35.42%
 
PS2 45 46.88%
 
Xbox 360 17 17.71%
 
Total:96
d21lewis said:
The_Liquid_Laser said:

That is probabaly true, especially outside of North America and Japan.  SNES games are more like modern games.  SNES games are easier and longer than NES games (as a whole) which makes them more like the games made today.  SNES games are 2D, so they feel a step or two away from modern games, but NES games are like an extra step and that can feel too far removed from modern games.  Also the NES doesn't use any developer tricks (things that subtly make a game easier), and this is great on an old TV, but it can make the NES feel off on an HDTV which generally has lag in it.  NES is more reflex based than any system that came later.

However, a lot of people (probably most people) who played both the NES and SNES when they were new systems prefer the NES.  There is a difference between looking forward (in real time) and looking backward having not lived through it.  There are several ways that NES games are better: 1) action is most intense on NES (less lag and "developer tricks"), 2) more first party games (3 Marios, 2 Zeldas, etc...), 3) light gun games, and 4) most importantly there is a lot more variety and originality on the NES.  One thing that makes a game good (and a console good) is originality.  On the NES, Mario, Zelda, Metroid and Tetris were totally original games (also Mega Man, Castlevania, Final Fantasy, etc...).  Everything was original.  Modern gaming is so far removed from this that it's hard to describe.  Breath of the Wild would have been another good game on the NES, but today it is game of the decade.  The NES was pure originality and today's gaming has almost none.

These are the reasons why the people who experienced the NES in it's prime consider it one of the best (or simply the very best) systems of all time.

Speaking only for myself, I got an NES in 1988 when I was 12 and absolutely loved it. Got an SNES in 1993 and loved it even more. Now, I still play SNES games but just the thought of playing certain NES games make me feel a little anxiety. I don't think I'll EVER play an NES game unless I'm just messing around for 5 minutes.

I appreciate what it did for the industry and my childhood but, like the PS1, most of the games are just too crude to be fun. I know I don't speak for everyone. I do like watching videos of the NES but mainly for the reaction of the players, and not because of the games.

Obviously, everyone has different tastes.  For me I've found that I like first party games better on the NES compared to their SNES sequels (Mario 3 > World, Zelda 1&2 > LttP, etc...), but I usually like the third party versions more on the SNES (Castlevania 4 > 1-3,  Final Fantasy 4&6 > 1, etc...). 

Another thing I appreciate about the NES though is that a fair amount of good games never got sequels on the SNES.  For example, Blaster Master is a great game, but there is no SNES Blaster Master.  NES had a lot more light gun games and I prefer the zapper to the super scope anyway.  And for action games with fast reflexes I prefer the NES.  NES games feel faster and more reactive.  For example, Links sword in Zelda 1 strikes fast and you can strike frequently.  Link's sword in LttP is more of a swing and so it feels slower.  It's like the difference between stabbing with a knife and swinging a baseball bat.  The former is just a lot faster.  NES games in general feel more twitchy, more reflex based.  

Old school (especially 2D) action games are not something the game industry does well anymore.  There are plenty of good ones on the NES, SNES and Genesis, and I like all 3 systems, but if I had to pick which one is the best for old school action then I'd have to say the NES.



Around the Network
The_Liquid_Laser said:
d21lewis said:

Speaking only for myself, I got an NES in 1988 when I was 12 and absolutely loved it. Got an SNES in 1993 and loved it even more. Now, I still play SNES games but just the thought of playing certain NES games make me feel a little anxiety. I don't think I'll EVER play an NES game unless I'm just messing around for 5 minutes.

I appreciate what it did for the industry and my childhood but, like the PS1, most of the games are just too crude to be fun. I know I don't speak for everyone. I do like watching videos of the NES but mainly for the reaction of the players, and not because of the games.

Obviously, everyone has different tastes.  For me I've found that I like first party games better on the NES compared to their SNES sequels (Mario 3 > World, Zelda 1&2 > LttP, etc...), but I usually like the third party versions more on the SNES (Castlevania 4 > 1-3,  Final Fantasy 4&6 > 1, etc...). 

Another thing I appreciate about the NES though is that a fair amount of good games never got sequels on the SNES.  For example, Blaster Master is a great game, but there is no SNES Blaster Master.  NES had a lot more light gun games and I prefer the zapper to the super scope anyway.  And for action games with fast reflexes I prefer the NES.  NES games feel faster and more reactive.  For example, Links sword in Zelda 1 strikes fast and you can strike frequently.  Link's sword in LttP is more of a swing and so it feels slower.  It's like the difference between stabbing with a knife and swinging a baseball bat.  The former is just a lot faster.  NES games in general feel more twitchy, more reflex based.  

Old school (especially 2D) action games are not something the game industry does well anymore.  There are plenty of good ones on the NES, SNES and Genesis, and I like all 3 systems, but if I had to pick which one is the best for old school action then I'd have to say the NES.

On the flip side, I watched a playthrough of Kabuki Quantum Fighter on YouTube and my recommendations are now filled with hidden 2D gems that I think would have blown my mind if I'd played them back then. 

Anyway, I'm rambling. I agree with you. We all have our preferences.



Easily the Super NES for me from that list and the Genesis would be next if we count that as Sega's second console.



I enjoyed the PS1 more than I enjoyed the PS2, so I'd have to give my vote to the SNES. Xbox 360 is a close 2nd, however.