I never thought any game could do it. When

in the first part and everyone was crying, I was mehing, but this is real shit, I forgot that I'm seeing 3D models, na mean.

... Ok.

I can only hope less people will say how RDR2 is the only game that's ever made them cry now. Could never understand how that game's story can get you so emotionally invested.

I just realized how stupid of 

First half an hour of the first game got me teared up

while the introduction of Sara was really well done it didn't get me emotionally invested enough in that short time to actually tear up, but it's very impressive that the scene stayed relevant to how the story events play out till the very end of TloU p1

That doesn't sound like fun.

The only game that me tearing was when snake had to fight boss in mgs3. Can't think of any since.

No game has made me cry. Ever. Kingdom Hearts 358/2 Days was close though...

I felt nothing