With the gen coming to an end this year and most noteworthy titles for at least Sony and Microsoft already being released or close to let's compare the reception and sales of the three platforms.
Reception will be from metacritic and GOTY from gotypicks.blogspot.com. Sales will be taken from VGC (so possibly twice as much was sold with digital).
Here for easyness of comparison I'll be calling 1st party all the true exclusives either made in house or contracted (so Until Dawn, Sunset Overdrive and Mario Rabbids count).
Sony
Astrobot Rescue Mission 90, 3 GOTY, 0.71M
Bloodborne 92, 31 GOTY, 3.11M
Days Gone 71, 2 GOTY,
Death Stranding 82, 80 GOTY
Detroit Become Human 78, 1.57M
Dreams 89, TBD GOTY Awards,
Driveclub 71, No GOTY, 2M Sales wiki, 2.37M
Ghost of Tsushima (TBD)
God of War 94, 198 GOTY, 6.15M
Gran Turismo Sport 75, 3.77M
Horizon Zero Dawn 89, 52 GOTY, 5.82M
Infamous Second Son 80, 3.01M
Killzone Shadow Fall 73, 3M
Knack 1 54, 1.88M
Knack 2 69, 0.47M
The Last Guardian 82, 15 GOTY, 1.29M
The Last of Us Part II 96,
Nioh 88, 1.07M
Nioh 2 85,
Ni no kuni 2 84, 0.89M
Persona 5 93, 10 GOTY, 1.64M
The Order 1886 63, 1.62M
Ratchet and Clank 85, 2.38M
Spider-Man 87, 16 GOTY, 8.76M
Uncharted 4 93, 165 GOTY, 10.33M
Until Dawn 79, 1 GOTY, 1.9M
Nintendo
Animal Crossing New Horizon 91,
Arms 77, 2M
Cadence of Hyrule 85,
Fast RMX 81,
Fire Emblem Warriors 74, 0.51M
Fire Emblem Three Houses 89,
Luigis Mansion 3 86, 1 GOTY,
Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle 85, 2.59M
Mario Tennis Aces 75, 1.87M
Metroid Prime 4 TBD
Pokemon Sword and Shield 80, 1 GOTY,
Pokemon Let's Go 80, 5M
Snipperclips 80, 0.12M
Splatoon 2 83, 7.04M
Super Mario Maker 2 88, 2 GOTY
Super Mario Odyssey 97, 26 GOTY, 11.71M
Super Mario Party 76, 4.97M
Super Smash Bros Ultimate 93, 4 GOTY, 8.95M
Xenoblade 2 83, 1.4M
Microsoft
Crackdown 3 60,
Dance Central Spotlight 74,
Dead Rising 3 78, 1.63M
Everwild TBD
Forza Horizon 3 91, 1 GOTY, 3.93M
Forza Motorsport 6 87, 2.02M
Forza Motorsport 7 86, 1.52M
Gears 5 84, 2 GOTY,
Gears Tactics 81,
Gears 4 84, 3.38M
Halo 5 85, 4.92M
Halo Wars 2 79, 0.51M
Killer Instinct 73, 0.11M
ReCore 63, 0.26M
Ryse Son of Rome 60, 1.47M
Sea of Thieves 69, 0.69M
State of Decay 2 66, 0.36M
Sunset Overdrive 81, 5 GOTY, 1.16M
Summary:
Sony | Microsoft | Nintendo | |
Sales Total | 62M | 22M | 47M |
Metacritic 90+ | 6 | 1 | 3 |
Metacritic 80-89 | 9 | 7 | 11 |
Metacritic 71-79 | 6 | 5 | 4 |
Metacritic Under 70 | 3 | 5 | 0 |
GOTY Awards Total | 573 | 8 | 34 |
duduspace11 "Well, since we are estimating costs, Pokemon Red/Blue did cost Nintendo about $50m to make back in 1996"
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8808363
Mr Puggsly: "Hehe, I said good profit. You said big profit. Frankly, not losing money is what I meant by good. Don't get hung up on semantics"
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=9008994
Azzanation: "PS5 wouldn't sold out at launch without scalpers."