hmm.. I'm bad a grading, but here is my positives and negatives..

neg:
- starting the show with GTA V.. really?
- tons of useless inbetween videos and waaaaaay too long design reveal stuff
- while not a full deep dive, I'd expected atleast 2 longer gameplay details videos in the style of the Horizon 1 reveal
- no turn based or atb jrpgs shown

pos:
- lots of existing IPs that make a comeback had great looking trailers (R&C, Horizon 2, DS remake, GT7, Sackboy, Astrobot,..)
- interesting new IPs from Sony, 3rd party and indies (Returnal, Kena, Project Athia, Little Devil Inside)
- not much talk/fast paced

neutral:
- console design
- no price/date (I expected that)
- no features etc talked about (I expect this to come in separate videos)

overall I felt it was a great show (my pos points are very condensed and weigh heavier than the neg ones)

Terrible take, no one is forcing you to buy the digital one, please feel free to get all the partial games in discs and then download the rest of it like you already do. But why should I have to pay for something i will never use (blu ray discs)? On the microtransactions that is an old hat too, clearly some games do microtransactions right, just because we don't partake in them, doesn't mean they are bad. Helps studios stay profitable while we enjoy the continuous game price drops (when accounting for inflation).

Agreed, 7 is the score I was going to give. Good pacing, nice presentation. Sony always nailed that with their E3 presentations.

Ratchet isn't my type of game but it looked good.
Project Athia looked nice but didn't see much at all.
Little Devil Inside had amazing style but I could have swore this game was shown years ago?
Deathloop also looked pretty nice. I am wondering if maybe it's PVP, one person as each of the assassins? That would be cool.

I was very interested in the Destruction All-Stars game at first but my desire decreased the longer the trailer went. I started thinking it was a next gen Wreckfest and then maybe a next gen Twisted Metal but watching the whole thing idk what the fuck it is and it doesn't look too appealing.

I also agree there were more than a few interesting games and a lot of it did look cross gen. For something a lot of people hyped as the showcase for why the PS5 SSD makes all the difference, I didn't see anything. Horizon 2 looked nice but it was not gameplay. It was like the Hellblade 2 trailer.

That console design though, what in the actual fuck? I have a history here of being against white consoles. Even taking the color out of the equation though, that design is goddamn hideous LOL. Very surprised to see they are going with a SAD edition, too. Wonder if the digital one has a larger SSD? It seems that would probably be MORE expensive? A BR drive can't be too expensive nowadays but doubling up on these expensive SSD capacities has to be pretty pricey.

So yeah, 7. Same score I'd give the Xbox show. Some cool new unknown games shown in both.

Nothing there a mid-range PC couldn't handle from last year. 

Lol, a high end PC shits its pants trying to play control at 4k with ray tracing, gtfo with some crappy xox with jaguar cpu xD

Btw, ratchet & clank is saying hi when transitioning from area to area with zero loadings. And as an aside, GT7 looks absolutely stunning, looking forward to see the dynamic weather teased during the video and how many fully detailed cars will be there.

I'm torn. the game releases were a 12/10 (Spider-Man, Horizon, Ratchet & Clank, and Demon's Souls remakes are 4 of the top ten most wanted games of all time to me), so that was amazing.

but no release date/price hurts and I am not a fan of the console design.

still a 9/10.

This Event was awesome :) My favorites are:

And some other new games. Cant wait to see the new Spider-Man on PlayStation 5!

depends on what you call a "mid-range PC" - something with a $500 graphics card?

Hope you're not using netflix or spotify either. Or PC gaming for that matter... btw how are things back there in the 1990's? Hot tip, buy Apple and Amazon shares ASAP.

I thought it was a good 8/10. I appreciated a lot of the games presented but the only ones I really want to play would be Ratchet & Clank (one of my favs IPs) and Horizon. Though sackboy and some of the indie games looked cool and I may get them at a later date.