Errr...  According to VGC, a total of 104 games have sold 600+ thousands on X1.  And if we compare that to the 172 games on PS4, and 8 games on the 3DS, then I would say is not that bad considering the more than double install base of those systems.

EDIT:  My bad, I made a mistake while looking at the 3DS numbers.  It is 92 games.

Holy shit. Charts are switch games everyhwere.

"Flop" is a relative term. For instance, if CoD sold 600k it would be considered a flop. If a game like Undertale sold 600k it would be considered a success. 

Btw I don't think most games are a flop on Xbox One, their sales just pale against PS4.

Holy F

No, I don't think it flopped. Skyrim is at 600k according to VGChartz, without digital, and it did that in like 3 months. It will easily pass a million and go beyond. Btw, it makes it even more impressive because Skyrim is a 2011 game that got remasters a year ago on current gen consoles and are cheaper on them as well.  Crash, on the other hand, is an one year old game that will release simultaneously on Switch, Xbox One and PC, so yeah.. if it does 800k or less, I'd consider it a flop. Btw, I wouldn't consider Skyrim on Switch a big success or anything, it's just performing decently.

Jeez chill guys. I was refering to games outside of the big blockbuster super marketed franchises just didn't write it idk i was tired lol it was 3 am.

We were talking about a colorful game that also happens to be a platformer and there is no way it will sell amazingly on Xb1. When you look at its track record, games like Lucky's tale barely sold 5k physical so even if the digital ratio is groundbreaking i can't see it being a success with all the promo it got. Crash isn't looking to chart high either. Sea of thieves isnt doing really well. Almost everything that isn't a main franchise or has guns and blood struggles on the platform. Its honestly a miracle Ori did okay. 

Kirby is already 22th in yearly.
Bayo 2 is 24th .
PS4's COD WW2 is 30th.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/bestsellers/2018/videogames/ref=zg_bs_tab_t_bsar#2

So Kirby moved up, nice! I checked yesterday and it was #24 on yearly. I'm curious to see FW sales.

I really wish we knew attach ratio for these consoles. I would guess that xb1 has a higher rate than ps4.

Amazon Hourly Ranking (11h from last update) :

Hardware:

1 (-) - Nintendo Switch Neon - 12 (+3) - 299.00$ - In stock
2 (-) - Nintendo Switch Grey - 17 (+3) - 298.99$ (-0.01) - In stock
3 (+1) - Playstation 4 Slim 1Tb Black - 32 (+1) - 298.99$ - In stock
4 (-1) - XBox One S 500Gb - 41 (-9) - 224.99$ (-3.01) - In Stock
5 (-) - Playstation 4 Pro 1 Tb God of Wars - 48 (-3) - 399.99$ - Preorder
6 (-) - Super Nes Classic - 67 (-2) - Third Party Sellers Only
7 (-) - XBox One X 1 Tb - 75 (+5) - 499.00$ - In Stock
8 (-) - Playstation 4 Pro 1 Tb - 76 (+8) - 399.00$ - In Stock

Out of Top 100 :

-

PS4: 3 (-) ; NS: 2 (-) ; XBO: 2 (-)

Software :

1 (+1) - NS - Super Smash Bros. - 4 (-) - 59.99$ - ??/??/18
2 (+2) - NS - Super Mario Odyssey - 5 (+2) - 48.99$ - 10/27/17
3 (-) - NS - Kirby Star Allies - 6 (-) - Out of stock - 03/16/18
4 (-3) - NS - Crash Bandicoot N Sane Trilogy - 7 (-4) - 39.96$ (-0.03) - 07/10/18
5 (+1) - NS - Mario Kart 8 Deluxe - 8 (+2) - 54.00$ - 04/28/17
6 (-1) - NS - The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 11 (-3) - Third Party Sellers Only - 03/03/17
7 (+1) - NS - Captain Toad: TT - 19 (+4) - 39.99$ - 07/13/18
8 (+2) - PS4 - Far Cry 5 - 20 (+6) - 59.96$ - 03/27/18
9 (-2) - NS - Octopath Traveler: WE - 21 (-3) - Out of Stock - 07/13/18
10 (+2) - PS4 - God of War 4 - 26 (+5) - 59.96$ - 04/20/18
11 (-) - NS - Splatoon 2 - 29 (+1) - 52.99$ - 06/21/17
12 (+1) - PS4 - Nino No Kuni 2 - 30 (+4) - 59.96$ - 03/23/18
13 (-4) - PS4 - Destiny 2 - 35 (-10) - 23.99$ (-0.01) - 09/06/17
14 (-) - NS - Mario Tennis Ace - 36 (+2) - 59.96$ - 06/22/18
15 (-) - PS4 - Call of Duty: WWII - 37 (+2) - 39.99$ - 11/03/17
16 (-) - XBO - Sea of Thieves - 42 (-) - 59.88$ - 03/20/18
17 (+1) - NS - Donkey Kong Country:TF - 45 (+2) - 59.99$ - 05/04/18
18 (-1) - XBO - Far Cry 5 - 47 (-1) - 59.96$ - 03/27/18
19 (+3) - NS - Hyrule Warriors: DE - 49 (+6) - 59.99$ - 05/18/18
20 (+1) - NS - Dark Soul Remastered - 50 (+3) - 39.99$ - 05/25/18
21 (+2) - PS4 - Far Cry 5: DE - 50 (+6) - 69.96$ - 03/27/18
22 (+2) - XBO - Call of Duty:WWII - 52 (+5) - 39.99$ - 11/03/17
23 (+2) - NS - Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle - 54 (+4) - 42.00$ (-3.92) - 08/29/17
24 (-5) - NS - Octopath Traveler - 55 (-5) - 59.99$ - 07/13/18
25 (-5) - 3DS - Pokemon Ultra Sun - 57 (-6) - 29.99$ - 11/17/17
26 (-) - 3DS - Detective Pikachu - 59 (-) - 39.88$ - 03/23/18
27 (-) - NS - Code of Princess EX - 64 (-) - 39.99$ - 09/25/18
28 (-) - NS - Pokken Tournament DX - 68 (-) - 48.75$ - 09/22/17
29 (+2) - PS4 - Devil May Cry HD Collection - 70 (+2) - 03/13/18
30 (-1) - Wii - Mario Kart Wii - 71 (-2) - 35.95$ - 04/10/08
31 (+1) - PS4 - Monster Hunter World - 72 (+1) - 57.99$ - 01/26/18
32 (+3) - NS - The Elder Scroll V: Skyrim - 74 (+8) - 50.16$ (+1.66) - 11/17/17
33 (+1) - NS - Arms - 77 (+4) - 48.99$ - 06/16/17
34 (-4) - NS - Bayonetta 2&1 - 79 (-8) - 59.88$ - 02/16/18
35 (+3) - PS4 - Titanfall 2 - 80 (+6) - 10.99$ - 10/28/16
36 (-) - NS - Rocket League: CE - 81 (+2) - 29.99$ - 01/16/18
37 (+3) - 3DS - Pokemon Ultra Moon - 85 (+8) - 33.90$ - 11/17/17
38 (+3) - XBO - Far Cry 5: DE - 88 (+12) - 69.96$ - 03/27/18
39 (R) - PS4 - Burnout Paradise Remastered - 89 (R) - 39.99$ - 03/16/18
40 (R) - 3DS - Warioware Gold - 91 (R) - 39.99$ - 08/03/18
41 (-2) - PS4 - Star Wars Battlefront II - 100 (-10) - Third Party Sellers Only - 11/17/17

Out of Top 100 :

33 (R) - PS4 - Gundam Versus - 75 (R) - Third Party Sellers Only - 09/29/17
37 (-13) - XBO - Far Cry 5: GE - 85 (-27) - Out os Stock - 03/27/18

PS4: 11 (-) ; NS: 21 (-) ; 3DS: 4 (+1) ; XBO: 4 (-1) ; Wii: 1 (-)