I watched the match just now. It was very good. Nothing amazing though. I don't follow wrestling anymore. But, I find it hard to believe the Jericho has never had a match that good before.
There's times I've question the scores. Brock Lesner has never had a 5 star, yet hes put on fantastic matches. Shawn Michaels only put out 2, which is crazy considering him being one of the best of all time. Same with AJ Styles, Meltzer only gave him 1 5 star match.