From these two options obviously Xbox One X. I've got my PS4 Slim for Japanese games and there is not really much reason for PS4 Pro in such games. I have almost zero interest in Sony's first party games and VR so I don't really need PS4 Pro. And as multiplats machine Xbox One X is way better: it's smaller, it's more quiet, it has better OS and Xbox Live.

The Pro and Scorpio are both upgrade hardware designed for enthusiasts and people already in the ecosystem, not so much to entice new customers. So it’s not surprising a bunch of people who prefer PlayStation and uh.. work for a PlayStation website would prefer a Pro.

I gotta say though, even if I preferred PlayStation, the Pro is such a weak upgrade, why bother?

I would love to have a reason to buy an X1X. I'm happy to pay for more power, and in general the X1X appears to be a better engineered piece of hardware than the Pro (though i appreciate the simplicity of Sony's approach to the Pro). I predominantly game on PC though, so i only buy consoles for their exclusives. Now that MS release theirs on the W10 store, the X1X has become somewhat redundant to me.

I doubt MS care that much, i'm investing a similar amount in software regardless, but i just can't justify an X1X. A console without exclusives is just a shittier PC to me. Maybe if i was rich i'd buy one just to admire it

Seeing as I already own a PS4 so I'll go for a PS4 Pro. Obviously lol.

All that needs to be said.

I have a Pro. I prefer Sony's exclusives so regardless of the power difference I don't have any interest in XB1X.

The Pro was my first PS4 = new customer at time of purchase.

If the X1X is worth it to someone whose previously expressed apathy to image quality/graphics (such as yourself), someone that already cared about those things is likley to value a Pro to a comparable degree. Especially since they're paying quite a bit less. I know I've been quite happy with the Pro. Not amazed, but it's been worth the entry price.

The dynamic obviously further shifts if you're dealing with someone that doesn't own a PS4 at all.

Hardware wise the Xbox Obe x is better. Games and exclusive wise Playstation pro is better. I prefer exclusice games over hardware otherwise I would have built a gaming pc better than both consoles combined.

Well I play both Xbox and Playstation because they both have exclusives I want to play.

I don't think I will buy a Pro because I'm content with standard PS4 specs while the PS4 Pro improvements tend be minor, a sharper picture in most cases.

I would like to upgrade to the X1X eventually it makes the most significant visual performance improvements. Also, I like using BC and what it does for that content is fantastic. Gears 3 for example looks like a remaster on X1X.