Don't forget though that site is very Nintendo/Zelda fan heavy. Not sure why that is.

I don't even think that's bad necessarily, but 3 fucking Zelda games! And the mediocrity known as Super Mario Galaxy, blegh.

The lack of Dark Souls, Halo, Banjo Kazooie, Doom, and Dorito's Crash Course practically disqualifies this list 

Dude, I think you need to realise that your list is totally niche, not many people regard Doom or banjo or DS as the best games ever I mean c'mon what are you smoking? Just go to Metacritic top rated games to get an idea, you will find alot of Zelda, FF, and GTA I would imagine.

....

lol

" not many people regard Doom or banjo or DS as the best games ever"

Actually a lot of people do. Like, a lot. They're just not Zelda popular. All those games are more popular and just as critically acclaimed by most people as Super Metroid. Wtf : P Also Halo and Gears definitely should have been up here. The only serious thing I said in this thread is that this list needs more diversity. You're taking a semi-serious comment to seriously.

But we polled 40 games which is pretty diverse

Darkwing Duck Turbograx16

Right, which is why I said he shouldn't have included 3 Zelda games ... I mean at least try to add some more 3rd parties, most of thes are Nintendo. 

The Witcher 3 including expansions.

But when he first made the polls, people were complaining about the lack of Nintendo games (if there's only one Nintendo game on the list, it's a very easy win for that game, since all Nintendo fans vote for it).

And the thing with Zelda is, the franchise is so diverse and most of the games are of very high quality.

That's because Nintendo makes the best games ever!