By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Geof Keighley's Best Conference E3 Poll? Microsoft wins!

jason1637 on 14 June 2017
Errorist76 said:

LOL Vasto...

This poll is a joke and was probably retweeted by XBox blogs and MS sites. You know the general opinion on the net is a different one. 

Wherever I go on the net the universal opinion was it was heavily disappointing and lacklustre. Sony's wasn't great but still better. Devolver Digital, Ubisoft and Nintendo still won by a margin! The fact alone Ubisoft came last in this poll shows it shouldn't be taken serious at all!

 

Do you have any evidence to back this up?



Around the Network
Panama on 14 June 2017

Well there you go, proof you can win without much in the way of new exclusives. Cant wait to replay Halo 5 on my Xb1X. Just kidding i can definitely wait.

Lets not kid ourselves, Nintendo did everything right this year, no way MS conference was better.



Airaku on 14 June 2017
Flilix said:

Does this guy post a lot of XBox related stuff? Because these polls have slightly different results:

http://www.thesixthaxis.com/2017/06/14/who-won-e3-2017/

https://www.kotaku.com.au/2017/06/who-won-e3-2017/

http://www.strawpoll.me/13181935/r

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=229428

Nah! He's the guy who runs the Game Awards and he has love for all of the platforms. If anything he probably gives Sony the most press due to his well known ties to his friend Hideo Kojima. Though he also has a lot of memorable and famous interactions regarding his relationship of Reggie. He's pretty much just does his job with as a game Journalist when it comes to Microsoft.  So no... He's mostly unbiased.

Keep in mind that this is Twitter so it's very likely that a lot of casual people who may not have watched the show just voted for their console of choice. I don't know.

PigPen said:
He is in Microsoft pocket. He been paid to tell that lie.

This is total horse shit and a straight outta E3 lie. Why would you even spread libel like that dude?




monocle_layton on 14 June 2017

Wow, an internet poll in Microsoft's favor!? Watch out Sony, seems like Twitter is your new rival



LudicrousSpeed on 14 June 2017
S.T.A.G.E. said:
LudicrousSpeed said:

Um, Sony has closed shows with multiplats as well. The last two PSX shows have closed with multiplats. They closed this E3 with a licensed video game from a third party developer. But per usual I'm sure it's different when Sony does it, for reasons :)

They closed psx with either the last of us or Spider-Man to my recollection. 

2015: Paragon

2016: Andromeda

2017 E3: Spider-Man, a licensed game from a third party

Of course for im sure this doesn't reflect negatively on Sony for you as it does MS.



Around the Network
Rafie on 14 June 2017

I know it's all opinion. I really do. However, I can't take that poll serious when they have MS that much ahead of everyone when it was pretty standard at best. Ubisoft had that best showing followed by Nintendo. I will say that as a presentation MS was better than Sony. For the games department, I believe Sony had a slight edge over MS.

Still Nintendo and Ubisoft are the real winners here. Nintendo's conference wasn't even all that to keep it real. Lackluster E3 for 2017.



PSN ID- RayCrocheron82

XBL Gamertag- RAFIE82

NNID- RAFIE82/ Friend Code: SW-6006-2580-8237

YouTube- Rafie Crocheron

ironmanDX on 14 June 2017
Flilix said:
jason1637 said:

No hes more of a Sony guy.

Also the amount of people voted in Geoff's poll is more than all those polls you showed combined.

I know, but these were the first 3 sources when I googled it.

If you would make a poll on EA their website, it would probably say that EA has won. So I'd say that the number of polls on different websites is more important than the number of voters.
That's why I was asking if he's a Microsoft guy, because otherwise the results seem kind of odd. I mean, almost everywhere on the internet people seem to think that Sony's presentation was at least as good as Microsoft's.

If you truly believed that you wouldn't have used vgchartz as a source. Microsoft fans are a minority here. Ouya has more of a chance at winning a poll count on here.



Imaginedvl on 14 June 2017
Rafie said:
I know it's all opinion. I really do. However, I can't take that poll serious when they have MS that much ahead of everyone when it was pretty standard at best. Ubisoft had that best showing followed by Nintendo. I will say that as a presentation MS was better than Sony. For the games department, I believe Sony had a slight edge over MS.

Still Nintendo and Ubisoft are the real winners here. Nintendo's conference wasn't even all that to keep it real. Lackluster E3 for 2017.

Yah... Oppinions :) 

How showing less games (far less), not having any kind of show and basically the equivalent of just projecting a YouTube channel full of trailers on a big screen (and calling it a conference) makes Sony conference slightly better than what Microsoft did?



Imaginedvl on 14 June 2017
ironmanDX said:
Flilix said:

I know, but these were the first 3 sources when I googled it.

If you would make a poll on EA their website, it would probably say that EA has won. So I'd say that the number of polls on different websites is more important than the number of voters.
That's why I was asking if he's a Microsoft guy, because otherwise the results seem kind of odd. I mean, almost everywhere on the internet people seem to think that Sony's presentation was at least as good as Microsoft's.

If you truly believed that you wouldn't have used vgchartz as a source. Microsoft fans are a minority here. Ouya has more of a chance at winning a poll count on here.

Like for real and it sucks some time :( All poll results on VGChartz are completly meaningless because of that.
Hell, you would ask if mathematically, 6TF is bigger than 4TF, I can tell you that you would have something like 70% of the vote saying no... Some results are so ridiculous on this website... 



IamAwsome on 14 June 2017

Does anyone have any social media information for all the conferences? That's how these things should *actually* be decided. Which conference got the world talking the most.

EDIT: Answered my own question. FanCensus