Well I only played Horizon Zero Dawn, but I would give it a 9.4.

wow and here people are bitching about a 70 for Zelda and this guy wants to give Horizon just a 9.4/100

Thats a troll score if Ive ever seen one.

I guess this thread won't be for people who haven't played the game.

Unfortunately I've only played a few of them, and Zelda is really getting in the way of me playing the rest lol

I'm perfectly happy with a 96-98 range for Zelda, and Shovel Knight's at 89 seems perfectly reasonable as well.

I do feel Resident Evil Biohazard has been a tad overrated simply for being one of the only engaging horror-VR experiences so far (from what I've seen on youtube where they played Alien: Isolation with VR headsets it would be far more frightening if they'd just provide an official VR version for it).

The main issue for me is that Resident Evil 7 is akin to playing your way through a scripted movie, which is to say it has some of the weakest actual gameplay in franchise history. It's certainly a cool experience (even if the horror is more comical than frightening), but I feel it's one that we'll be less impressed by in the not to distant future when looking back.

Still, I'd be fine with 78-82 for it, so it's not like it was grossly overrated or anything. Haven't played any of the others.

Well I meant a 9.4/10 but I guess I could downplay it until a 9.4/100 if I combine a few troll reviews. I mean the detail alone is so distracting from the gameplay it deserves 75 points less than a 94. AI is also suicidal AF so that's bad for people who suffer from depression or know someone struggling with suicide, so that's another 10.5 points off. Hence a 9.45

Ot of those games ive only played Shovel Knight. I'd give Shovel Knight a 8.4/10.

Yakuza Zero 8.0/10
Dragon Quest VIII 7.0/10 (My views from the PS2) (I might be harsher in the past, but basically not a fan of this). 
Zelda 9.5/10 <--- Would most likely be in my top 10 games, not top...nothing has yet to beat Final Fantasy IX. 

Will play Horizon after Zelda and Mass Effect and Persona.

I would give Horizon a 9.2, and Nioh 9.0. Haven't played any of the others yet.

1. >=95%

2. Haven't played

3. Haven't played

4. Waiting for PC release

5. Haven't played

6. >=85%

7. Haven't played

8. Haven't played

9. Not getting the game a third time on 3ds, but >= 90% for PS2 version. 86% seems about right from what I know of the 3DS version. 

10. Haven't played 

Only played Horizon out of those, I'd rate it at around 8/10 myself. Great game, but with some fairly big issues that are impossible to ignore.