onionberry said: So far the most negative review, and to be honest it's not that bad in my opinion. Considering that Vincent Ingenito is not a nintendo fan and is very cynical about Nintendo. Some valid points and some that are dumb in my opinion, Not portable enough? well I guess my ipad and my laptop are not portable enough, comparing the power to the ps4 and xbox one is dumb too considering the concept and form factor (and price) but overall not that bad for a negative review. Doesn't sound like a "hater" sounds like someone who doesn't like the system. But I have to say, the score part is a joke. "not a final score but I will say 6.7" just wait until the final review man. |
there's something questionable about IGN deciding to put basically a guy who is negative about Nintendo on to review the system. They should have put someone more in the middle.
When the guy is whining about, essentially, the hybrid concept as a whole (which naturally would make for a home console that's not as powerful as the competition, that being the whole point, that it trades off power for more gaming options and portability) as well as whether the system can fit comfortably on his shelf.... that says a lot.
i.e. he's biased for whatever reason or doesn't like Nintendo
you'll notice in his whole 'review' beyond a few small parts he essentially doesn't really have any arguments for the console quality, ui, controls- any of it being bad.
at one point he even phrases a sentence that says something along the lines of, 'if such and such haven't already bothered you then there's this and this (insert a few negative things)'. Very strange wording in some of the article from what is supposed to be an unbiased reviewer
In the end its fair to criticize the launch library, its fair to criticize the controls (if you don't like them), its fair to criticize a number of things- but when your primary criticism is essentially that you don't like the hybrid concept because its not a tiny portable and now a powerful home console- that's just incredibly weak.
The guy even says that the UI menus in the system are so-so, when everyone for the most part has raved about them being smooth and quick from launching the system, to going through menus, to starting games.
Whatever. I never did like IGN but a 6.7 just seems like an especially silly early rating when the quality of the system appears extremely high and the biggest negatives the guy has are essentially about it fitting on his shelf and being a hybrid. Note: having a poor launch library doesn't really speak about the quality of the system, and I would presume a 'system review' is more about rating the actual hardware
Note: the battery complaints are getting old, Nintendo stuck the largest battery they possibly could into the system if you look at the 'guts' pictures. Try playing the Witcher 3 on a tablet, even an optimized Shield type of thing, and see what happens. Mobility power is just not there yet for high demanding apps, without melting the system. maybe if you attached a big fan to the system to keep it cool