By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - MGS4 VS GTA 4


gta sell better
MGS4 - higher ratings

Around the Network

For me I think that MGS4 will be the better game, but I just like linear games best. For sales, I think if you count just PS3 than MGS4 might be able to pull it off, since it's bundled.



...

Tuanniez said:
Well It's hard to say, but one thing is for sure. GTAIV Will sell better. But on the rating side, the GTA series on the ps2 were rated very high, higher than the MGS series if I remember right. Both are great games, and if both scored crappy, I'd still buy it. Reviews don't mean too much these days.

No they both got the same ratings, MGS2 got a 96 above all GTA's according to Metacritic.



 

mM

GTA4 will sell far better, but the ratings of the two games will be close- though MGS4 will edge GTA4 out.




i have a feeling gta will get higher rating. can anyone get the ratings from each previous games.



 Next Gen 

11/20/09 04:25 makingmusic476 Warning Other (Your avatar is borderline NSFW. Please keep it for as long as possible.)
Around the Network

I'm pretty sure they will both do really well, but, as with everyone else on here, I think that GTAIV will sell more, but MGS4 will get (slightly) higher ratings. I'd imagine both will average over 90%, though.



leo-j said:
Tuanniez said:
Well It's hard to say, but one thing is for sure. GTAIV Will sell better. But on the rating side, the GTA series on the ps2 were rated very high, higher than the MGS series if I remember right. Both are great games, and if both scored crappy, I'd still buy it. Reviews don't mean too much these days.

No they both got the same ratings, MGS2 got a 96 above all GTA's according to Metacritic.


Yes, thats MGS2, MGS3 has a score of 91, so average wise, GTA is still higher. But both MGS4 and GTAIV will get scores  of 90+ so really, not gonna matter too much =D any game 90+ is a must play to me really. I have both of these games on pre order already, so they can get +1 to sales for me haha.

I agree with almost everyone when they say GTA 4 will sell more but MGS4 will get better ratings, but its likely that GTA 4 might get better ratings.



DMeisterJ said:
Sell Better: GTAIV
Better Game: GTAIV
 
Fixed

 



starcraft - Playing Games = FUN, Talking about Games = SERIOUS

They are both gonna be badass in my books, but i really concider them a completely different type of game so i can't compare them.



Current Consoles: Xbox 360 Elite, Playstation 2, Gaming Rig, Nintendo Wii, Playstation 3.

Xbox Live: Jessman_Aus - Playing: Ace Combat 6, Fifa 09

Playstation Network: Jessman_Aus - Playing: MGS4, Resistance 2

Wii Freind Code: 3513-9191-8534-3866 - Playing: SSBB

Brawl Code: 1590-6125-1250

Xfire: J3ssman - Playing: Fallout 3, Farcry 2

Jessman: Fears the Mangina