padib said:
Mummelmann said:
I'm asking it as a general question now. Many posters seem to be of the opinion that there simply is nothing to criticize about the NS concept and the teaser, I'm merely curious if jumpin is one of these users. There's a middle ground between ultimate doom and full on blazing glory, something this site seems to have forgotten, or perhaps never knew at all.
What about you, do you see any potential problems with the concept and the teaser?
|
I know that Nintendo will be lacking games to show. I think there is an underlying problem too. But I don't think OP presented it properly.
I think choosing to do a teaser was the right way for Nintendo to go, because as I explained to torok in another thread, Nintendo always gets bashed when they show too much. People will always find something to fault them about. It's become a habit to bad-mouth Nintendo. So I personally believe they are doing the right thing to show less.
However, knowing Nintendo, I can see that they will have a sluggish start in terms of games, because they have a lot of 3rd party support for handhelds, but games for this will require much more dev time. The jump from 3DS to this is immense.
Having said that, the DS also was off to a very slow start, but it eventually took off. I personally believe the same will happen on Switch. Slow start, worrisome at first but imho Nintendo has a winning formula with Switch so I think it's not worth it to worry about too much.
Sorry it took so long to reply I was ultra busy yesterday and haven't been on since.
|
No worries, man, just came home from a 30 hour shift myself...
Well, you are someone I consider above average intelligent on these boards, and you make some good points. A teaser in itself may not be a bad idea, I disagree more with the actual content, and the somewhat confusing message from Nintendo in calling it a home gaming system when emphasis seems to lie on the mobile aspects, this is doubly confusing when adding the fact that they've denied that this is the successor to their actual handheld line, for now at least.
I think they're walking a dangerous path, they're going more or less right at the tablet segment of the market, with software that would otherwise not be played on tablet or smart devices, there's a good reason why most bigger and more complex software isn't published or widely played on tablets and phones. I think that the tablet form factor could harm more than help, it puts them directly in the line of fire in addition to causing certain limitations on things like battery life and, to a lesser extent, mobility. They need to convince what appears to be young adults and proffesionals in their 20's and 30's (if the teaser is anything to go by) that they want to carry with them an additional smart-like device, I think that it'll be a really tough sell. I fear they're going to place themselves somewhere between markets again with this solution.
The teaser and feel of this whole thing is also more like that of smart devices, where they spring details on you practically on the eve of launch, this is not how one traditionally shows and presents more static devices in consumer electronics, and this is another suggestion that they're actually chasing the smart-device touting young person. I'm just not sure that the typical Mario and Zelda fans, or Nintendo fans for that matter, are the same as this phone and tablet worshipping crowd (yeah, I know, Pokemon Go, Pokemon is its own thing since way back when and most people who play Go don't own a Wii U, for instance).
In short; Nintendo are seemingly, once more, trying to force a new market into being, not unlike with the Wii, which had an actual, unique hook for its target demographic with software that really complemented the hardware. They are pairing this with the attempted double-edged appeal of the Wii U, which we know failed spectacularly, and this has me worried for real.
I wanted Nintendo to sit down, analyze and respond to the market in a clever way, they are not in a position to simply whack together devices in order to be different and not think about whether or not the thing has an actual demographic.
Maybe I'm paranoid, dumb, or both, but I have a pretty bad feeling about the whole concept and the (in my opinion) somewhat confusing message(s) from Nintendo themselves regarding the whole thing (it's not a successor to handhelds, it's a home gaming system and not a hybrid, yet they focus mostly on mobile aspects, it makes no sense what so ever to me).
Maybe there's a master plan that I can't see, it wouldn't shock me, but it wouldn't shock me if there wasn't one either, to be honest.