I'm torn between The Witcher 3 and the Uncharted Collection (never played an Uncharted before).

I'd say The Glitcher 3. You can play that game until the world ends, while with the Uncharted Collection you rush through the three games and that's it.

The witcher 3. No contest. The amount of sheer content is absolutely ridiculous. Already clocked in 20 hours just for the DLC(haven't finished yet). Put in around 110 hours for the actual game.

Depends what you're in the mood for, how much time you have. If you're going to have a lot of free time I recommend the WItcher 3, if you're only going to be able to fit in short bursts of gaming I'd recommend the Uncharted Collection.

Though you could get Uncharted Collection now as Witcher 3 will probably get a GOTY version soonish.

I've been meaning to get around both but I've been trapped in the free-time-quicksand-pit that is Ark: Survival Evolved.

Seriously, I think I've put like 100+ hours into it already... can't stop. There's far too many games these days.

Depends on what game type of game you want to play, and what are your priorities for a game.If you value more story, then go for Uncharted.If you value more exploration, the Witcher 3.I would personally say, as a package, the Uncharted Collection is the best one, even though The Witcher 3 can be argued to be the better game.

Both is the answear :p

Really hard decision!
I would choose The Witcher 3 first because it's the more recent game.
But I would definitely buy the Uncharted Collection somewhere in the future too because it is such an amazing trilogy.

Witcher by a landslide