In the case you exposed, games like Uncharted 4 on last gen consoles would look much worse, yes, and you still dont understand that we are talking of  the game as it is right now, maybe a 240p version of this game with no AA, shorter drawn distance, a simplified physics system, and downgraded lighting and textures will work fine on PsVita... but that's not the version of the game we are talking about, that's not the version of the game that has impressed even Digital Foundry, is this one, the game as it si right now is impressive for a WiiU, compared to all game I have played on the system this looks beyond what the console looked capable of.

Also the comparison XBO-Ps4 is a bit different, they can always lower the resolution of the xbo version to balance the difference, in the case of Ps3 -WiiU however to lower the resolutiobn would result in a sub-hd game, and that difference is remarkable, would this game be able to run in Ps3 at 480p? I guess so, but again, that's not the version we are impressed about, that does not make the WiiU version less impressive for the hardware than it is.

Errrrr I guess you were talking that Zelda would look much worse on PS3, not that UC4 would look much worse on PS3 (in this case yes we could agree, altough seeing what they accomplished in UC2 and 3 I wouldn't worry too much). So you think WiiU is so much better than PS3 that they would need to downgrade everything in half? Ok keep gaming on the power hog you have there.

Eh... no, those are only your words

I have never considered my WiiU a specially powerful console, specially since my PC must be like 5 times more powerful, but I can see when a game is pushing the console beyond any other game on the system, and that's why I'm impressed, this is using some modern techniques that I see on some of my PC games but I would not expect to see them on a hardware like that in the way Zelda is doing it.

You are claiming Zelda would have to be 480p to run on PS3.

No I didn't, it was clearly an example.

So basically you can't really say how much worse it would be and also have no hard proof of how much stronger WiiU is than PS3 (all I know you can pull is some dev saying that to then the console was stronger, that was at release). So we are back at square one with you having no evidence to claim it's impossible.

So basically you can't really say how much worse it would be and also have no hard proof of how much stronger WiiU is than PS3 (all I know you can pull is some dev saying that to then the console was stronger, that was at release). So we are back at square one with you having no evidence to claim it's impossible.

What is yours for saying the opposite? 

Mine is my eyes and a good memory, because most people seem to have a terrible amnesia when it comes to remember graphics of last gen games, the only open world game that cames remotely close to this one in Ps360 is GTAV, the most expensive game ever, and yet, it doesn't look as good as this on those consoles and it runs at 20fps half of the time, hopefully this will have a mostly stable framerate in release. Tachikoma made an analysis about XCX and she concluded that the game was not possible on Ps360 at least without making remarkable downgrades in some areas. This looks better than XCX and has a way more complex Physics sytem and AI so that makes me think this would not be possible on ps360. 

Like 99% of games today, but then they would look much worse and the comparison makes little to no sense, I find impressive that the game as it is and it looks right now is able to run in the WiiU, I'm talking about the actual game as it is, not about a heavily downgrade version of it.

And when WiiU is running some games that ps360 would not be able to run without remarkable downgrades because they are more demanding is pretty logic that it would be able to run any ps360 game, included tlou, because they aren't that demanding.

Which PS4/X1 game?

No one game in particular, but looking at that DF footage, If this was a PS4 game I wouldn't bat an eyelid. Its not cutting edge but it also doesn't look last gen to me either.