By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Movies & TV - 'Captain America: Civil War' Review Thread - 90% RT/75 MC score - WW BO = $991.0M/DOM = $314.2M

I think if Marvel/Disney wouldn't know that they have a winner they wouldn't release the movie a week later in USA and some other markets and would try to release it WW in the same week.

It's funny when you look at IMDB and how the movie got 1/10 from 18% of all voters yet but well, in the end some thousand fanboys won't do too much to the audience scores. It's not like the Metacritic user scores for some exclusive console games^^



Around the Network
crissindahouse said:

I think if Marvel/Disney wouldn't know that they have a winner they wouldn't release the movie a week later in USA and some other markets and would try to release it WW in the same week.

It's funny when you look at IMDB and how the movie got 1/10 from 18% of all voters yet but well, in the end some thousand fanboys won't do too much to the audience scores. It's not like the Metacritic user scores for some exclusive console games^^

How many 10/10 does it have?



binary solo said:
It's still got a long way to go before it can be guaranteed to have a RT score above 90, but 37 out of 38 reviews being fresh and still averaging 8.3/10 is damn good. Dis' ting gonna be uuuuge!

8.3/10 is about Skyfall or Star Trek level of score.



Lawlight said:
crissindahouse said:

I think if Marvel/Disney wouldn't know that they have a winner they wouldn't release the movie a week later in USA and some other markets and would try to release it WW in the same week.

It's funny when you look at IMDB and how the movie got 1/10 from 18% of all voters yet but well, in the end some thousand fanboys won't do too much to the audience scores. It's not like the Metacritic user scores for some exclusive console games^^

How many 10/10 does it have?

More but there is a clear difference. First of all a 10/10 doesn't help a good movie as much for the average score as a 1/10 will harm it (since the average is already much closer to a 10/10) and secondly most who voted 10/10 already will be from Marvel fanboys who will really like it that much even after seeing it. If they give it a 10/10 already or maybe a 9/10 after they saw it, well... But most who say 1/10 already before seeing it are people who would never give it that score if they wouldn't have an agenda. 

You can't really complain about a fan who really loves something but people who hate on something just for the sake of it are just lame. 

But after 500k votes in a year or so the fake scores in both directions won't do much



Updated the FP (been having trouble accessing the VGchartz). You can expect a flood of international reviews starting from today. I'll update international grosses as the day goes by. I'll be seeing the movie on Saturday but I'm trying to see it later tonight if possible.



PS4/PS3/PC/3DS Owner (Will buy a Switch when mainline Pokemon game is released)

Around the Network

I will see it in 3 hours, let's see how my third "superhero" movie this year will be.



crissindahouse said:
Lawlight said:

How many 10/10 does it have?

More but there is a clear difference. First of all a 10/10 doesn't help a good movie as much for the average score as a 1/10 will harm it (since the average is already much closer to a 10/10) and secondly most who voted 10/10 already will be from Marvel fanboys who will really like it that much even after seeing it. If they give it a 10/10 already or maybe a 9/10 after they saw it, well... But most who say 1/10 already before seeing it are people who would never give it that score if they wouldn't have an agenda. 

You can't really complain about a fan who really loves something but people who hate on something just for the sake of it are just lame. 

But after 500k votes in a year or so the fake scores in both directions won't do much

No, the fanboys who voted a 10 won't change their minds after seeing it no matter what - they've made up their minds before seeing the movie, afterall.

 

And the average is closer to a 10 simply because there are so many fanboys giving it 10/10.



Lawlight said:
crissindahouse said:

More but there is a clear difference. First of all a 10/10 doesn't help a good movie as much for the average score as a 1/10 will harm it (since the average is already much closer to a 10/10) and secondly most who voted 10/10 already will be from Marvel fanboys who will really like it that much even after seeing it. If they give it a 10/10 already or maybe a 9/10 after they saw it, well... But most who say 1/10 already before seeing it are people who would never give it that score if they wouldn't have an agenda. 

You can't really complain about a fan who really loves something but people who hate on something just for the sake of it are just lame. 

But after 500k votes in a year or so the fake scores in both directions won't do much

No, the fanboys who voted a 10 won't change their minds after seeing it no matter what - they've made up their minds before seeing the movie, afterall.

 

And the average is closer to a 10 simply because there are so many fanboys giving it 10/10.

The "fanboys" who gave it a 10/10 will like the movie even after seeing it. like I said, even if they would try to be honest they would still give it probably a 9/10. It's not as if they will be like "ohh damn, this movie is a 3/10 but I give it a 10/10". They will be maybe like "this movie was a  8-9/10 but I still give it a 10"

But most haters who gave it a 1/10 will think that it deserves a better score and with better iI don't mean a 2/10^^

And wtf about:

"And the average is closer to a 10 simply because there are so many fanboys giving it 10/10"

I mean, sure, just believe that the average audience score is only above 5.5/10 because of fanboys and not because the movie deserves simply something above a 5.5 in the opinion of the average audience ... you really believe the score would be below a 5.5 without fanboys? Hahahah sure. Let's look after some 100k votes when most who voted are "normal" people who aren't "fans"

But why do I try to tell you this, you have made up your mind about this and probably all other Marvel movies released under Disney long time ago, right?

BTW when I posted about the many 1/10 votes 20% of the votes were a 1/10. It changed now to only 12.4% so that it is not really anything we still have to talk about...it's still much worse as it will be in a week or so but already much less as yesterday or whenever I posted it. 

Batman vs Superman has only 3.9% of 1/10 votes (with some Marvel fanboys voting it down) so I think that this is a number Civil War will probably reach as well with enough votes. 



We know live in a world where a Captain America film is doing better critically and will likely have a better run at the box office then a Batman vs Superman film.

just WOW



animegaming said:
We know live in a world where a Captain America film is doing better critically and will likely have a better run at the box office then a Batman vs Superman film.

just WOW

It's also an Iron Man and Spider-Man movie.